Oscar is too old for Floyd but Shane is just right for Cotto?

The only explanation behind this that I can fathom is that Mosley has been more active than DLH.

However, I have said since people were calling for PBF to fight Mosley BEFORE he signed to fight DLH, that Mosley was older and I am still not sold on his being "back". I don't buy that win over Collazo as a coming out party. We shall see though.

 

Kind of like how Judah is considered a great win for Cotto while some fans were upset that Floyd fought Judah and don't give him as much credit for the victory.

I agree with kg - the only thing I can think of is because Mosley fights more often than Oscar.

 

or that Cotto is a great fighter for winning titles in two weight classes, and Floyd is a fraud for being a titlist in 5 divisions and champion in 3.

 

I mean what the heck is up with that:blood

 

:deal only WBO titles matter, not titles or championships.

 

To be fair, I think Cotto IS a great fighter. But he should not get any more slack than anyone else when it comes to resume and titles. I would feel more comfortable with Cotto being labled great and rated highly P4P if he had actually beaten the champion for his belts, but both were vacant when he won them.

 

I think he is too, I just find it laughable that a titlist is celebrated higher than the champion who has fought in 5 diff. weight classes.

 

tell me where that makes sense. I am glad has never had to fight for a wbo title. I mean how many ring champs have a wbo title (i know calfaggy)

 

floyd maybe champion according to some book but cotto is the peoples champ :yep

 

I think you know PBF has earned his titles. Regardless, this is more about Mosley really and Cotto's credit for fighting him while PBF gets less credit for fighting the younger but "old" DLH. What's your take on that?

 

i never thought de la hoya was old, he was inactive and rusty, but not old, he showed he can still hang with the best.

 

:good

 

dam striaght you hit ti right on the button why is cotto the number one contender to floyd's title cuz he beat judah:-(

 

ok then who else do you think should be number 1? margarito? cintron?