P - o - u - n - d - f - o - r - p - o - u - n - d - t - o - p - 1 - 0 - 0

A great effort. I must get round to doing this one time...

 

Dinamita, please do watch the saddler-elorde fight..i hope you would have a better understanding how great flash elorde was?

i really like the way you rank saddler..he should be penalized for being a dirty fighter for most of his career

also, i put around 10% criteria on timeliness..monzon longetivity was matched by hopkins...thus, monzon's greatness diminishes a bit imo


i read you 4 criteria, where would you put timeliness there? or would you ever care to put timeliness as part of your criteria? ali is so timeless so he should in top 6 at the very least..

 

you forgot to add the legendary:

JULIAN "MR. KO" LETTERLOUGH

 

Its a great list, and something which I will refer back to when I become more familiar with a few of the names. I'm interested to see that there is clear air and a few spaces between Chavez and Roy...

 

after the KO of margarito, i would say the shane is up there with benitez..how would you factor in the illegal use of substance of shane..he might be using banned substance his entire career..

 

i put jimmy wilde at the top 20..he is so dominant with power punch and a one punch KO artist at flyweight.

 

Mosley is top 100 for sure

 

Where the hell is Elorde???

 

i think its just fair that elorde is not there..tough i would put him around 85-95.. he put saddler at 25

stanley ketchel is too high ..