P4p Head to head, top 10 boxers ever?

Well then you should watch more boxing

 

Paul Williams at 147 p4p against anyone, yep
Roy jones, yep
George foreman h2h kills almost everyone
I'll choose Leonard over Duran for head to head for the simple reason that Duran is too small at 147 and a bunch of taller boxers will cause too many problems- Leonard at 147 gives anyone a fight

 

He's a poor mans whitaker with a big mouth

 

No its most likely you are complet re****ed. But that´s ok. Mayweather tends to attrack African American teens with very little education. They like rap, bling and loud talkers. I guess in a couple of year you will claim the same about Broner.

 

To be honest while all this is true and you do know your stuff, your Mayweather opinion is shocking.

One does not simply get outboxed by Castillo and an old ODLH and damn near the same to Maidana and get called one of the most brilliant boxers you've seen. Unless you're talking like one of the 50-100 most brilliant or something like that.

Sure, everyone has a bad day here and there but his career is a relatively small sample size and the amount of top-level opponents he's faced makes it even smaller.

Gonzalez is a particularly :huh-worthy entry, too.

 

That's actually one of the funniest and most misguided rants I've read on here. Good work.

 

Roy Jones Jr
Floyd Mayweather (SFW)
Sugar Ray Robinson
Wilfredo Gomez (SBW)
Sugar Ray Leonard
Lennox Lewis
Salvador Sanchez
Marvin Hagler
Pernell Whitaker
Roberto Duran

 

Gonzalez? The guy who ducked Raymi?

 

Predictably high occurrence of Roy Jones in here

I just wonder how we can put a guy into a top 10 p4p/h2h list when he has a notorious glass jaw and no record of protecting it against top opponents. I could see a guy like Ward being mentioned or a ton of other guys who are known to have been dropped/stopped/put on giraffe legs a few times, but only if they fought a high level of opposition without that happening. We've all seen Mayweather hurt but that was what, once or twice in a long career of facing champion-caliber opponents? Roy faced Toney ffs. That's great but it was one fight. I would not feel comfortable putting him up against literally every other boxer who ever lived...he's absolutely bound to get stopped more than a few times.

Guys with weak chins and no real defensive skills who relied on athleticism and soft matchmaking aren't going to cut it in this discussion. You need a guy who's going to stand up to the punches he's bound to take when fighting other great fighters, or defensive skills so amazing that he won't take the punches in the first place. That's why guys like Hearns can't make the list, and if it applies to Hearns it applies to Jones (who would have been KO'd more times than Hearns had he faced anywhere near the challenges).

 

You sound like a 13 year old using his father computer , wtf is this reply ? you make yourself look like a real idiot , but i guess you dont care cuz your too cool for school , 13 after all...

 

Top 10 is just too much for any fighter today , Floyd can talk about his flawless career where he fights twice a year and Manny can do his thing and move up through the weights , but fighters back in the the 50's , 60's and 70's fought 6 times a year and almost fought a round robin of the absolute best , so for me there is no one today who gets anywhere near.

The closest I have seen would be Roy Jones at 168, however his roid abuse will always question how quick , strong and stamina based his talents really were.