P4P in their prime whos better RJJ or PBF?

They are different. Jones more talented and impressive, but Mayweather in technically better. The result is the same, they can both dominate opponents and win.

 

Good post.

Although I would favour Roy on an all-time p4p list, and in a p4p H2H match - when both in their primes. So I went with Roy (but not by MUCH at all)

 

Roy by far for me

 

I'm gonna go with Floyd ... two different eras though ... roy started in 89 and FLoyd started in 96 ... it took Roy longer than Floyd to get a world title ... and to achieve p4p status.

Roy's reign was 93-03 w/ 4 weight classes and a DQ loss in between ... and no one really appreciated roy (outside of his fans) until he lost ...

Floyd's reign is from 98-08 w/ 5 weight classes and is still reigning as p4p king ...

Both are great stellar careers ... and are on the same level ... Roy's HW championship trumps Floyd's SWW champions, but the fact that Floyd is still reigning says this discussion has to be revisted once Floyd and Roy hangs up the gloves.

 

RJJ is the most talented fighter ever

 

easy, RJJ.

 

Roy Jones by a comfortable margin.

 

rjj by a very long way

 

:-(

 

I can almost guarantee that when Floyd has left boxing for a few years - or loses a few times when he's past it, even if he keeps fighting on when he should retire - the "by far" will be dropped. As PBF is p4p no. 1 and at his height, just like it was for Roy, there's a lot of hatred/dislike from a number of fans.

This will change over time, as it normally does.

With that said, I still went with Roy.

 

Jones beat better opponents and did so in more dominant fashion, so the answer is clear: Jones.

 

Floyd had some controversial close decision wins during his prime, (Castillo, DLH). During Jones prime, he barely lose a round.

Jones clearly for me.

 

:huh

For realz?

 

RJJ he was a god with gloves.