P4P LIST - As of March 18, 2008

Suit yourself; you aren't going to convince anyone who doesn't agree with you, though.

 

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pac
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Juan Manuel Marquez
6. Kelly Pavlik
7. Israel Vasquez
8. Bernard Hopkins
9. David Haye
10. Joan Guzman

 

Yeah, true. But YOUR pretty much always going to rate yours as being better than BTDs.

On the other hand, however, BTD is always gonna rate his as being better than yours.

There's a road block, either way.

To be honest, I haven't really looked at either too deeply, so I can't comment.

 

I'll go one better; I'll stop commenting on p4p lists altogether.

 

No way in hell Kelly Pavlik is one of the 10 best fighters on earth. Far too many flaws, he sticks out like a sore thumb on these lists

 

This is not true. I have seen better lists than mine and I've changed my kind accordingly. Others have changed their mind after seeing mine...this is how people learn and improve.

 

Does he not have a better claim to being in the Top 10 than Hopkins?

There, I've done it:roll: ...I've commented on p4p listsatsch ...broke my promise already...:-(

...never again.:deal

 

Don't mind him, I recall him picking Winky to stop Hopkins back in July.

In fact, I think I'll bring that guy back to life for some good old fashioned forum fun that this forum seems to be lacking.

 

Amsterdam...you need to bring back the fun!:happy :happy :happy

This content is protected

 

Probably, but I love to see Hopkins rated highly. Presumably these people will have to move Joe up to 1 if Mayweather continues rasslin and chasing De La Fishnets whilst Joe beats a p4p top 10

It disturbs me a guy like Calderon is so underrated, and a sloppy fighter like Pavlik is a dead cert, after beating 2 even more flawed fighters than himself

 

Right...so you only pick Hopkins high because you have an agenda, now that Calzaghe is fighting him...:nono

This. Is. Wrong.:deal

 

Nah, I posted my list on the last page

No Pavlik or Hopkins in sight :deal

 

Hopkins isn't even top 25.:deal

About to get served a hardy annihilation, then I'll get to rub it in the faces of all of the Taylor and Hopkins apologists who just DONT get it.:yep

 

No because Hopkins beat the same guy that beat RJJ twice and hadn't tasted defeat since Glenn Johnson in 04' ... I think that Hopkins gave Tarver his first legit loss of his career.

There was no dispute who won ... there was controversay in the first fight with RJJ, and the first fight w/ Glenn Johnson.

That Harding fight was bull**** - he had a broke jaw and still went the distance.