Everyone has a list and when I start reading, everyone always disagree that this person should not be there and that person neither but here is my p4p list and I dont like boring fighters so some of the usual fighters on any p4p list may not be here but I will rate them in and order of who has more power, skills, chin. record, fights and has prove himself. Let me know what you think and please all those Floydettes dont be sending me comments that he should be #1 please 1- Manny Pacquiao- power, condition, skills, and he has prove he is the man 2- Gamboa- he has the best skills in my opinion, best fighter I have seen in my life, he has power, more skills than Pacquiao but we have to wait until he fights better opposition 3-Juan Manuel Marquez- too bad he is on his way out but I think he has more good fights on him, he looks very old 4-Montiel- No one talks about him but his skills are great and he has some real punching power 5-Rafael Marquez- best jab I have seen, great fighter but he is on his way out 6-Lucian Bute- He is just becoming a star but he will be going up in the p4p list soon, got power and the skills 7-Dirrell. I dont like him but he has the best reflexes, great power and counterpunch 8-Martinez- Sometimes he runs too much but he is a skilled fighter 9-Mosley- old man still has the power and skills 10- Pirog- too bad hbo didnt interview him but this kid has skills to beat anyone, I dont know about power because I think that punch on Jacobs was a lucky punch but we have to see Vasquez- he is out but he could had been right next to Marquez Dawson- great skills but no heart, too robotic like wladimir Klitscho, people called him p4p but one lost chaange the view of many and thats why Mayweather is not in the list Mayweather- he fights just like calderon, i have always said it, its so hard to beat someone who runs like a chicken, calderon was p4p and after the loss he is in no one list and it will happen to Mayweather soon the same, no power lately Both Klitschos-wladimir is very boring and I like vitali but when I see Ali's videos, these 2 dudes dont deserve to be in the list. if tyson was active, nobody would know who the brothers are but they keep winning. I applaude them Cotto-Why people have Cotto on some lists, he is on his way out, he is good but not for p4p Ward- I wanted to put Ward but he seems to slow to me, we have to wait Haye- he better go with Fraud on vacation, ****in chickens, where are the real men who love fighting anyone Williams- he is a very hard fighter to beat but I dont think he is a p4p and I can bet he can beat Pacquiao, martinez again but no p4p Donoire,Juanma, Robert Guerrero and Jacobs could had been on the list Julio cesar chaves jr will be on the p4p soon, I hate that his father protected him so much Hopkins- I cant believe people put him as a p4p, he is so boring, he still beats everyone out there but someone who holds and punches down there cant go on my list Devon Alexander- this kid has great skills but with no power, he aint going p4p no where soon Adamek- he wont make it with the heavyweights, too small Tavoris Clous- no stamina, his body just looks impressive, thats all but no p4p Abraham, Froch and kessler are out Berto, Maidana,Khan, Bradley not yet Chris John- I dont like his style Caballero had an ugly style but he looked great on his last fight like he has a new trainer, that style may bring him in the p4p eventually Mares- not yet for p4p
So great movement and defense which is a major quality in boxing and what usually brings out Gold medalists is "running like a chicken"? Both you and your list are worthless. Learn what boxing is about first before creating trash lists.
Not a boring list true. I think the reason Floyd shouldnt be there is not because of his style but its because hes not fighting.
I don't usually comment on people's P4P list because it's all a matter of opinion and if I have somebody at 5 and I see somebody has him at 8 or whatever, it's not a big deal, but this list is terrible. Seeing Gamboa at 2, Bute at 6, Dirrell at 7, and Pirog at 10 made me laugh.
Gamboa has better skills than any fighter in any list, Pirog has better movement than many people, better defense than many, great to faint, thats my opinion, have you seen any one with better reflexes than Dirrell
Great movement and defense Watch Pirog's waist movement and thats called a great movement, avoid punches not running from punches, when you see guys running all over the ring people start booing and many of us called it running but some of you called it boxers. its just opinions
Skills should only be part of the equation when doing a P4P list, what needs to be factored in as well is achivements, resume, weight, etc. not just skills. If it was just skills why isn't Calderon, Donaire, Mayweather, and even Judah in on your list? Anyway, if that's how you decide your P4P list that's fine. It's your opinion and you do whatever you want with it.