P4P Ranking ..... Wheres Cotto ????

Had he beaten Marquez convincingly, or at least deserved the decision in my eyes, I would have put him number 1 or 2. But I felt Marquez won a close, but clear decision. Therefore, I kept my list exactly the same.

 

Calzaghe would be about 5th on my list, if I had one. 4th or 5th.

 

:rofl oh ****...please do everyone a favor and just leave, we have too many morons as is

 

Where would you place him if he beat Hopkins convincingly?

 

Definitately top 3.

Although that depends if the real Bernard Hopkins turns up and doesn't get old.

 

Yeh you have a point there. I also had JMM winning a close but clear decision, if that makes sense (kind of an oxymoron) . I chose to keep Pac at 2 cause his resume is much better than Joes and he just comes to fight and doesn't control the cards at all. If JC stops BHop (like I think he will) then I may move him to #2

 

One thing is for certain with BHop: he will show up in the best shape possible, no doubt. But he has slowed noticeably in the last half dozen years

 

Why the hell would you move him up based on a fight with Alphosno Gomez? FFS...

He should be fairly high already, around 5 by my reckoning

 

because i dont have your beloved floyd high on my list..? stfu:good

 

Many people posting didn't move him up. I am having a tough time between him or JMM at #4 though. I'm giving Cotto the nod for #4 right now because he looks to be in his prime (or damn close) and only Mayweather gives him a 50/50 fight imo

 

01. Manny Pacquiao
02. Miguel Cotto
03. Void Mayrunner

 

nice to see a non-biased list :blood

 

I've Cotto behind PBF, JMM, PAC, Calzaghe and Vazquez on sixth right in front of Winky and B-Hop (Rafa 9th, Mosley 10th)

Winky above Hopkins? Yes!
I had him in front of Hopkins before there fight and didn't see more than a draw for Hopkins. Ok ... maybe a 115:113

I think it's somehow funny, that almost everyone deleted Winky from theri P4P-List because of the wide margin at the official scoring for Hopkins-Wright (way to wide...)

IMO Marquez won twice against Pac (first 113:112; second 114:113)

 

Top 5