P4P Top 10

Pretty good list I will say, I would put Dawson and Williams below Wald and exchange one of the Dawson/Williams/Abraham with Adamek at #10.

 

1. Pacquiao
2. J-M Marquez
3. Hopkins
4. Cotto
5. Williams
6. W. Klitschko
7. Mosley
8. Donaire
9. Hasegawa
10. Caballero

 

how is mosley in front of cotto if cotto beat mosley??

 

Abraham?? The guy hardly got past Lujuan frikkin' Simon, for Christ's sake!

David Haye?? Who has he fought in the last year and a half?

I disagree with having Klitschko on there, but it's understandable. The other two are just stupid.

 

Arguably, Mosley is better than he was that night (he did run out of gas pretty quick, whereas he battered Margo with ease). And, arguably, Cotto is worse than he was that night (didn't look brilliant against Clottey and Margo took him apart).

 

what up with

This content is protected

hasnt been on for a looong time

 

1) Juan Manuel Marquez*

2) Manny Pacquiao*

3) Bernard Hopkins

4) Miguel Cotto

5) Shane Mosley

6) Paul Williams

7) Joshua Clottey

8 ) Chris John

9) Nonito Donaire

10) Celestino Caballero


*can go either way



thats MY LIST

 

Move Wlaadimir to 10. Take out those other 3. They're not there quite yet. Haye's done nothing for some time, so have can you remove Marquez and Vasquez and have him there? Makes no sense.

 

Pretty good list. Difficult for many to agree on a p4p list - espeically since it can never ben proven right or wrong. However, yours is as close to the objective right one as we will probably get. I think Hopkins should be a couple of spots higher, and Vitaly, Kessler and Juanma should be just around the 10th spot. Am think Haye, Williams, Wlad and Abraham deserve to be in the list.

 

In the Spanish Boxing Magazine top 10, this is probably what it would look like.

In a more objective list which has an understanding of what goes on around the world and not only fights that are broadcast to latinos, the initial poster's list is imo. far better.

 

1. Pac
2. JMM
3. Mosley
4. Hopkins
5. Williams
6. Cotto
7. Dawson
8.Donaire
9. Wlad Klit
10. Vitali Klit

 

1.pacman
2.jmm
3.paul williams
4.hopkins
5.mosley
6.cotto
7.juanMa lopez
8. donaire
9. clottey
10. calderon

 

1. pac
2. jmm
3. hopkins
4. mosley
5. cotto
6. pwilliams
7. wlad
8. donaire
9. calderon
10.dawson

 

Maybe because since that Margarito beat Cotto and Mosley beat Margarito and Cotto was really struggling in the last fight?

 

1 Manny De Piedra Pacquiao
2 Juan Manuel Marquez
3 Floyd Mayweather
4 Bernard Hopkins
5 Shane Mosley
6 Wladimir Klitschko
7 Miguel Cotto
8 Chad Dawson
9 Paul Williams
10 Nonito Donaire