p4p Top 15

Good list. I'd have Wlad at 9. Drop Ivan to 11.

Love the fact that you see PW as the 3rd best boxer in the world.

I don't see how people can argue with that rating but rate justify Mosley being at 5.

EDIT - Im just going to post mine.

 

I think Williams and Dawson are too high (although both are still in the top 10 in my opinion).

Abraham over Pavlik will cause some debate as well

 

I disagree with Williams. How can Williams be too high and not Mosley?

 

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Paul Williams (can be switched with Hopkins but hes been inactive)
4. Bernard Hopkins
5. Shane Mosley
6. Chad Dawson
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Juan Manuel Lopez
10. Ivan Calderon
11. Kelly Pavlik
12. Nonito Donaire
13. Arthur Abraham
14. Chris John
15. Mikkel Kessler


Past 10 is such a wash, you could mix and match them anywhere. Although I think Pavlik gets very overlooked for his one loss to Hopkins who is at 3/4. While Mosley who lost to Cotto (and Mosley was not in the ratings at the time, its completely overlooked)

 

viC still makes top 15 IMO.

otherwise good list.

 

Juanma
Donaire

Need to do something else to get in my top 15 they are great talents but they aren't quite there yet.

 

williams and dawson too high. where's vazquez and adamek?

 

agree

 

#1. Vitali Klitschko
#2. Floyd Mayweather
#3. Paul Williams


who gives a **** about the rest?

 

Like I say, its just my opinion :good

 

shouldn't kessler and hopins be 1 and 2, after all they did give the greatest fighter of all time close fights!

 

I don't wanna look like a nut-hugger

P.S Kessler fight wasn't close

 

youre waay past 'nut-hugger' :rofl