Im not really sure what H2H is, SOmeone explained to me when I was young p4p was if both fighters were the same weight but i tend to rate p4p on acomplishments in there weight and through weights rather than thinking if two guys were the same size can you tell me the differance between H2H and p4p, and rate these brits in p4p and H2H for me? Naz Hatton Khan Cheers
H2H Hatton v Khan. A year ago, I would have picked Hatton. Now, I'd favour Khan, but very much a 50-50 bout IMO. Hamed knocks them both out in first round :deal
Everyone seems to forget Hatton beat Tzysu and had a very good run and never lostto a fighter who wasnt less talent then him, something khan already done. But khanstill has a lot of time to create his legacy and hatton is already done
But when ranking the top 10, do you still take into account victories that happened years ago? If so, what time span are you taking into account, 10, years, 5 years, 3 years 1 year? :huh For example Manny just lost to a fighter coming from two weight divisions south, wouldn't that make JMM the #1 P4P fighter in the world? based on the most recent achievements, and even if you thought Pac actually won, it would have to be a very very close win, or those the fact that JMM moved up 2 divisions to fight doesn't matter because there's about the same size? I doubt any of those 3 are top 500, Boxing has had a long History of great and very underrated and unknown fighters, Kahn is top 1000 at best.
Well, i wasn't being serious with that last part of my post. But going on history, P4P, which two boxers are more likely to be knocked out? :think
Does the fact that Marquez came from 2 divisions down matter at all? If May went up to 160 and fought Martinez, and at the very least had a very close fight with him, would that be enough for you to rank him above Martinez? Floyd would be moving up 2 divisions, that has to count for something right? IMO Khan is not top 1000 yet, based on achievements, when he beats Bradley and a few other big names in their prime he'll be right in there.
You scored the fight for Pacquiao? So you have no problem at all with some of Boxings worst decisions in History? What's your list? 1.Marquez 2.Pacquiao 3.Donaire 4.Martinez 5.Mayweather (hard to belive people actually have him at #1:rofl)
H2H at the same weight, I think Khan > Hatton > Hamed > Khan. Styles make fights. P4P, it's Hatton > Hamed > Khan almost without question.
Khan; Hatton; Marco Antonio Barrera Kostya Tszyu Kotelnik Carlos Maussa Salita Collazo Malignaggi Urango Maidana Jose Luis Castillo McCloskey Juan Lazcano Zab Judah Paul Malignaggi Surely Khan's List is the more impressive, and all achieved at a younger age. Does anyone think Khan would lose to Hatton prime v prime?
