Pac vs whitaker at 145

sometimes throwing no punches and bending your hips is called defense

 

We need Sweet Pea in here to have a heart attack and call everyone a pedophile. Whitaker threads just aren't the same without him.

 

Looks like harrison got another alias.

 

The Pea of 135 would beat anyone at that weight in the modern era except maybe Duran...that fight would be a toss-up.

But you brought up a Pea at 147...the one that fought McGirt and had a lot of trouble in the first fight in NYC as well as early in the rematch in VA.

A 7-5 win over McGirt in the first fight wasn't dominant. McGirt was Top 10 P4P at the time, but so was Cotto in his fight with Pac. And Pacquiao lost two rounds out of 10 en route to a stoppage. That's 8-2 with 2 extra pts in the margin for the KDs.

In McGirt's rematch with Whitaker, Buddy scored a legit KD and had Pea hurt early. Whitaker was not invincible at that weight.

And you are fooling yourself if you think McGirt was miles ahead of Cotto as a welterweight champ.

I think Pacquiao would be an underdog but a live one capable of beating Whitaker. It would be a matter of Whitaker being able to neutralize Pacquiao with his signature off-beat jab he used, well, on McGirt in the second fight. But come on now. Pacquiao is not McGirt, styles-wise, speedwise, or powerwise.

 

Whitaker.

 

Whitaker at 135, Pac at 47.

 

I agree with this. I think all those guys are good opponents but the think with Cotto and Hatton is that they have been in too many wars

 

Pac

 

All old and retired fighters get totally over-rated. Sweat Pea would get knocked out at 147 by Mosley. Mayweather, Pac and Cotto.

 

******s are funny

 

They would be doing something that neither prime Tito or Oscar could do to a washed up Pernell then....:deal

 

are you serious ?

Now I know you havent seen Whitaker fight.

 

Whitaker outboxes Pacquiao at any weight, believe that ****, its true, oh yes, its true.

 

Pea is a terrable style match up for Pac.

 

:good