Pacdbest's Deserving current Top 10 P4P!!!

Floyd out of the top ten

Seriously man you need to put down the pipe

 

I like your list. Its a fan's list and not a wannabe Ring magazine writer's list.

 

Margarito in the top ten? Very cool. I will see how well he comes in off a fight with Cotto, seeing as he lost to Paul Williams two fights ago. But still cool to see that.

 

lol :rofl

 

I don't know if these are top 10, but they deserve some mention:

- Joel Casamayor
- Joan Guzman
- Steven Luevano
- Vernon Forrest
- Ricardo Mayorga

 

Mayorga beat a proven Fernando Vargas albeit a passed prime Vargas, but so is Mayorga. Calzaghe beat a Kessler who's credential was basically an undefeated record and the fact the he was still in his prime, but Calzaghe is arguably still in his prime as well. Calzaghe beat a well passed prime Bernard Hopkins who also moved up in weight (from the weight he normally fights at). Yet Calzaghe makes it in the top 10 of most people's list, but not Mayorga?

Mayorga beat Vernon Forrest twice who had beaten Shane Mosely twice. Mayorga loss a controversial decision to Cory Spinks which could easily have been given to Mayorga. Mayorga moves up in weight and takes on ATG Felix "Tito" Trinidad, and knocks him down, but Mayorga eventually loses. Mayorga beats Michel Piccirillo who was 44-2. Mayorga moves up in weight to lose to Oscar De La Hoya. Mayorga then beats Fernando Vargas. All in all, Mayorga fought the best in two divisions with the exception of a couple names. He won some and loss some, yet can't seem to muster enough respect from boxing fans.

Luevano may not be top 10 yet, but he's definitely top 3 at 126 lbs. now.

Casamayor is a great fighter who was always underrated. Casa had beaten Diego Corrales, Jose Luis Castillo, and Michael Katsidis. If he's not top 10, he's pretty close.

Joan Guzman is top 10 material, and if not pretty damn close to it. He's undefeated, and beats everyone impressively. His most notable wins are Humberto Soto, Jorge Barrios, and the late Agapito Sanchez.

 

pac by ko

 

Anything you can say to justify Pac at number 1 P4P eh?

Pac is number three, behind Floyd and JC, and will stay there until one of these guys retires.

 

No way is Joe over pAC. A no. 3 spot is reasonable for him but can be overtaken by Cotto after the Margo fight.

 

Calzaghe is definitely behind pac even after defeating hopkins, pac has clearly acheived more than calzaghe

 

Surely after he beats mijares he would be in p4p. But to say now he should be there is too premature at this point. Btw, aren't you angry at your pal donaire for saying pac should not have won the rematch with jmm? It's also there at wiki..oops sorry the mouse here sucks...

 

Surely after he beats mijares he would be in p4p. But to say now he should be there is too premature at this point. Btw, aren't you angry at your pal donaire for saying pac should not have won the rematch with jmm? It's also there at wiki..