Pavlik - Abraham who has the better MW & SMW resume?

Pavlik and Abraham 2 fighters that were in the MW division at the same time and now the SMW division.
So whos MW resume is better? and
Whos SMW resume is better?

Your opinions?

MW tough one, possibly AA based on overall with amount of defences but wouldnt argue either way


SMW Id say Pavlik even though he only has had the one fight in the division, beating Taylor for the 2nd time. I think its better than AAs win over Miranda and KO win over Taylor coming off a KO loss.

 

Pavlik fought better guys on the way up than AA fought as a world titlist.

Pavlik is 13-1 with 11 KO's above 160.

 

They are both over hyped equally.

 

At least both lost their most important fights (Kelly twice)

 

Weighing in above 160 does not equal 'fighting at SMW', as has been pointed out to you many times.

 

Good points, but AA did have a good win over Eastman

 

Boo, who has the better middleweight resume, Hopkins or Pavlik?

 

Pavilk wins over taylor means he takes this.AA would beat him like a ginger stepchild if they fight

 

:happy

 

Ya -- the guy who lost 5 rounds to Lujaun Simon can handle Pavlikatsch