PBF vs Big Show in a REAL boxing match

Yet to damage them you need to be more skilled, or equally skilled but with more power, or less power, equall skill, and more stamina...et. al...You are factoring out the skill part all togehter, and that is incorrect. Skill is paramunt in Boxing more so than any other sport. Mentl skill and Physical skill. You dont need pure skill to be succesful in other sports, i.e. Trent Dilfer, as the team can compensate for your shortcomings. In Boxing, its all their for the world to see. Very rarely will a less skilled fighter beat a more skilled fighter unless another variable is in place, focus, prep, chin, etc. They both will be skilled however, and usually equally Never will a "fighter" with no skill beat one at the height of his game...which is what you are asking me to beleive.

 

..At the end of the day, we will never know the answer....but it sure is fun to specualte..oh yeah, and one mroe thing....I AM RIGHT

 

Small Welterweight vs. EXTREMELY BIG HEAVYWEIGHT = Big Show Destroys Mayweather.

 

He is only HW in stature, not in skill. I lilely would not get a license. By your estimation, bigger = better, regardless of training. Wrong.

 

Now thats a real stetch to assume he is going to land "punches" on FMJ....over several rounds...which is another stretch to assume he can last several rounds...and what do you factor that leads you to beleive that A) he can land punchES on FMJ B) If he did, they would be of consiquence B) He has the stamina to go 12 rounds C) FMJ's rib punches will have no effect

 

Ok..I am bizzare...but you are the one saying a 400lb 7ft oafe can beat the peak conditioned boxer. C'mon. You are saying punches. You made that clear. I think we can agree that his punches would not equal force using basic priniciples of science, but rather would be slow moving blows....a punch with 150lbs of mass behind it traveling at 40mph has more force than a punch with 400lbs of mass behinfd it traveling at 2 mph....so, FMJ would hit harder..and has been hit harder...so you must be saying a points victory..

 

big show is nackered after chasing PBF around the ring for 3 rounds. PBF then uses all his strength to push him over and win by KO

 

You do need skill, or equal skill to your opponent. Perhaps in this scenario, neither one is skilled, and lucky punches can land. Therfor, skill is equal, and power can become the deteming factor. The opponent would need to have either A) slightly less skill to allow you to land the punch B) have the intangible of being echausted, less stamina C) Not have the mental endurance to train or overcome adversity. So, all these things can be assumed for BS, not FMJ...so it looks like in probabilty if a KO occured, it would be BS going down.