I scored the fight for Edgar, but I disagree with chimba here. Saying "without the first round" is like saying "well, if you dismiss 20% of the fight and it's most significant action..." True champions want to leave little doubt in regards to the discussion of who is the best. Edgar took Penn's title with a questionable decision. Edgar gave Penn an immediate rematch, as he should have, and gave an emphatic answer. Maynard defeated Edgar, I think narrowly, in their first encounter. I gave Edgar the next in what was officially a draw. There is some doubt in regards to who is the best UFC lightweight. We deserve an attempt at clarity. We're getting it.