1.Sergio Martinez Argentina 2.Juan M Marquez Mexico 3.Yurikois Gamboa Cuba 4.Giovanni Segura Mexico/USA 5.Abner Mares USA 6.Miguel Cotto Puerto Rico 7.Orlando Salido Mexico 8.Robert Guerrero USA 9.Brandon Rios USA 10.Anselmo Moreno Panama 11.Victor ORtiz USA 12.Fernando Montiel Mexico 13.Miguel Vasquez Mexcio 14.Juan M Lopez Puerto Rico 15.Jhonnny Gonzales Mexico 16.Humberto Soto Mexico 17.Gullermo Rigondeaux Cuba 18.Hugo Cazares Mexico 19.Miguel Acosta Venenzuela 20.Omar Narvarez Argentina 21.Rafeal Marquez Mexico 22.Antonio Margartio Mexico 23.Roman Gonzalez Nicaragua 24.Marcos Maidana Argentina 25.Erik Morales Mexico 26.Chirisian Mijares Mexico 27.Kermit Cintron Puerto Rico 28.Alfredo Angulo Mexico 29.Mikey Garcia USA 30.Juan DIaz USA Others Yohnny Perez,Luca Mattheyusse,Jorge Arce,Saul ALvarez,Ulises SOlis, Victor Terraza,Nehonar Ceremeno,Ivan Calderon,Yoan Hernandez,Jorge Salgado,Jorge Linares,Marco A Barrera,Eric Morel,Ricardo Cordoba,Cristobal Cruz,Urbano Antillion alot more on par with these guys but id have to list another 20 or 30. This was a hard list to put together.. For instance i was tempted to put gUERRERO,,sALIDO ,Rios over Cotto as i dont think he is that dominant or will be at JM ;.. I think in a pfp fantasy matchup those guys would beat him. ..But ill wait on that one... Rigondeaux was hard too as i think hes talented enough to be higher,but he has to prove it against other guys then just COrdoba who gave him a helluva a close fight... Also wanted think Canelo is talented enough to probably be here but want to see him against a legit contender. Morales gets in for arguably beating Maidana, i actually thought it vould have went either way.
interesting project Ill get one made up before tomorrow morning. The only thing that really stands out in your list is Mares being rated abit too high nd JML too low imo otherwise pretty solid list.
Jesus for a second I thought you meant ATG and I almost **** myself literally (got one in storage.) I think I'd put Rafa ahead of Rigondeaux though...but nice list!:good
Good list I'd have Roman Gonzalez (light flyweight?) higher looked a great little fighter if its the same guy
I think Lopez is still rated pretty decent and over some good guys,,however hes also shown some flaws that some guys above him (if in the same class) might expose..But i hear you, there is not much seperating alot of guys on this list either. As for Mares well i though he edged Perez who at the time was very high on my list.. Also looked tough in edging Darchinyan. I think Agbeko,Mares,Vic,Perez were all pretty much even matched and i give all of them props for fighting eachother in back to back tough fights.... Perez though has seemed to fall of a little...If Mares was in some other division i think he would stand out more and dominate,BW is stacked on top,and IMO the best division in boxing.
:thinkYou know you are right... I guess at the time i was thinking Rigo is hot and Marquez on the way down..but RIgo hasnt done enough, and whos to say Marquez doesnt have enough left to put Rigo out and let him know hes messing with the big boys... GOod call.
I think ability wise he could probably be up there,but i wanna see him against better opposition first... Also still questions about his chin.. I decided to put Mikey Garcia over him because he has beaten better opposition,and it seems like hes proven more and answered more questions. Mikey hasnt beaten elite or top 5 contenders but hes beaten some solid fringe, lower top 10 guys,prospects guys who could test him and show what hes got.
Yey lot of these guys are close.. But i also think Juan could still suprise some people or give anyone besides JMM all they want at LW..JW was never his weight class, and besides i thought he edged Paulie the 1st time ,its just the scorecards were way to wide.... And no shame in losing to Marquez. Especially after doing real well in the 1st fight.