Poll:Greater fighter, Legacy and Champion Joe Calzaghe or Wilfredo Gomez?

Gomez and its not even close.

 

I'm not even going to go into any detail, because I believe the answer is obvious and unquestionable. It just has to be Gomez.

 

Gomez, no question about it.

 

It's Gomez and its not even close

Wifredo Gomez record 44W 3L 1D 42KO's

3 weight world champion (WBC Super-Batamweight Champion, WBC Featherweight Champion, WBA Super-Featherweight Champion)

17(17KO's) defense's of his WBC Super-Batamweight belt

Record in world title fights 20W 3L 0D 18KO's

Fought all time greats while they were in there prime Salvador Sanchez, Azumah Nelson and Carlos Zarate.

 

End of thread.

 

Their careers are not too far removed from one another comparatively, you can nitpick about the wins of both men if you really want to diminish one's legacy to boost the other's in this argument.

Gomez was better, it's subjective, i'll go with the consensus.

 

Agreed Gomez probably edges it but its a lot closer than a lot of these people would have you believe.

 

Once and for all...WILFREDO GOMEZ...and I like Joe Calzaghe by the way, but it isn't even a legitimite question, at least not for the Classic Forum.

 

I hate to be agreeable but Wilfredo by a mile

 

It's "Bazooka" all day,any day,now,tomorrow,next year & for ever more, comparing Wilfredo to Joe is just like comparing prime rib 2 cat ****:smoke

 

i didn't even get a vote.i could have only made it 11-0

 

I think somebodys glue-sniffing.

 

Yo, is that an old Barbados Joe Walcott

 

It is.