Poll: Who truly won both fights, J.M.M or Manny Pac. Vote/state reasons who won!

i have the first fight 113~112 and the second fight 114~113 both via a razor-thin win. i have no problem if they will fight a third time.

 

tied for both. I would've given 2 fights for pac, but the 1st one is a draw, and there is no choice for "draw". i thought it was inncredibly close, and i thought it was for pacquiao because he worked hard, he's the one initiating contact while marquez is just waiting in a long range (good strategy though).

 

Look at you all angry coz your set-up poll is not giving you the answers you wanted! :fire

 

thought Marquez won the first and pacman won the second. In the first pacman won the first 2 rounds and won them big. he hurt Marquez badly. After that I think that the judges had a preconcieved notion going into the other rounds and scored some for him that should not have gone his way uner the assumption that he was still being as effective as he was in the first 2.

the second fight was very very close and I had it 6 rounds a piece with the knockdown making the difference.

Both fights were close enough that you are going to get big time scoring disparities and you can make an arugment for either guy in either fight.

 

No option for two draws atsch

I would say that Marquez won both, but only by a point each time - but would have no problem with anyone saying Pacquiao won both, or 1-1 or two draws!

 

the person who got the decision WON the fight, all that matters is what the 3 judges say.....

no one else matters, not the fighters, not me, not anyone else........there's always gonna be a different opinion, but thats all that is, an opinion....the facts are Pac won twice, end of story

 

My god the idiocy of you people is amazing. You are the third person in the thread that says that the official decision is all that matters and then goes on to say that Pac won both fights. I'll say this one last time nice and clear so there are no more stupid mishaps.

This content is protected

That being said, this is a boxing board. We are fans and we from time to time like to discuss past fights. We know that our opinion is just an opinion. if you don't like the discussion simply go somwhere else.

 

I think in the first fight Pac won the first 2 rounds soo big, that alot of the close rounds in that fight were scored for JMM under the assumption that Pac was not as effective. JMM was admirable but I thought that was a close and decisive win for Pac who had built too huge a lead,.....the second one could've gone either way with JMM having a legit arguement for the victory. Nonetheless, I think Pac won both fights.

 

where is the walrus

 

Who do you think won each fight, if you have it 1-1?

 

They are pretty much tied in my book. Although on the # of rounds won, JMM has it.

 

I had Pac winning the first by a point and Marquez winning the second one by a point.

Actually, whatever people think on these two fights is acceptable.

They were THAT close.