Pound for Pound top 25

JMM should be above Calzaghe. Pavlik is a little too high, he shouldn't be above #7, Hopkins shouldn't be above #10, purely on the basis he's lost 3 of his last 5. Mijares should be a bit higher, Williams a little lower, Haye probably a touch higher aswell though #18 is more than reasonable. Campbell should be a bit higher, Vitali Klitschko probably shouldn't be in there just yet.

 

pretty different from my list,but thats a good list m8.

 

22 Vitali Klitschko
this ain't right

 

Good list, but I would definitely place Juan Manuel Marquez above Joe Calzaghe.

Nonito Donaire should be in there ahead of Joan Guzman - simply being talented is not enough justification for being p4p ranked, or RJJ would still be no1 as he is still active. Guzman has done **** all over the last couple of years and his resume is shocking. Edwin Valero, Joshua Clottey, Lucian Bute and Steve Cunningham should all be ahead of him - at least they are all active and winning. If Winky isn't in there, neither should Guzman be.

Also, I think you have Rafael Marquez a bit high, but that's just personal choice.

 

ain't right as in he should be higher or lower?

I would move him up in the top15. He is at the very least better than his brother, even at 38

 

Margarito higher! good list though.

 

cotto should be higher

 

1. Pac
2. JMM
3. Mijares
4. Calzaghe
5. Pavlik
6. Chris John
7. Margarito
8. Vitali Klitschko
9. Kessler
10. Hopkins
11. Vasquez
12. Abraham
13. Donaire
14. Miguel Cotto
15. Rafa Marquez
16. Wlad
17. Steve Molitor
18. Jorge Linares
19. Chad Dawson
20. Fernando Montiel
21. Lucian Bute
22. Nate Campbell
23. Shane Mosley
24. Haye
25. Daniel Santos
26. Jermain Taylor
27. Paul Williams
28. Ricky Hatton
29. Joan Guzman
30. Andre Berto
31. Ivan Calderon
32. Timothy Bradly
33. Steve Cunningham
34. Antonio Tarver
35. Joshua Clottey
36. Juan Diaz
37. Celestino Caballero

 

After the Darchinyan fight, Mijares' ranking should go up!!

Viva Mijares!!

 

Darchinyan has already been taken care of easily by Donaire. Most people already rank Mijares ahead of Donaire so i don't think Mijares will go up much when he beats Vic

 

I'll only allow myself one criticism, Pharaoh; I think Bute's too high. So far, he's not clearly proven himself to be B+ level, yet. I think there are more than 20 fighters out there better than him, from what we've seen. IMO.

 

Would be interesting to see a logically argued case for Arthur Abraham being ranked higher than Hatton, Kessler or Haye, given that all of their achievements outstrip his comfortably. It can't be a case of him being unbeaten as we see Cotto higher still.