***Prime for Prime: Joe Calzaghe Vs Roy Jones Jr.***

one sided beating ending with jones stoping JC

 

I'd say jones by UD, 7-5 or similar. I dont think Jones was that much better that he would have KO'd JC, but it's not impossible, he has extremely good power and Joe can go down... but I've never seen him hurt properly, he seems to be able to shake a great punch off in a matter of seconds

 

i think people forget that the Joe that fought hopkins wasnt a 'prime calzaghe' so enough of saying well he only just beat a 43yr old hopkins! think it would be closer than a lot of people are suggesting

 

A better chin doesn't win fights. The only thing Calzaghe has over RJJ is a better chin, and it's not like one punch and that's it. The weakness of Roy's chin is exagerated.

 

This is the most pointless poll of the decade. Who would win between an all-time great and a guy who has lingered around the top 5 P4P for a couple of years. It's like asking who would have won between Roberto Duran and Kostya Tzysu or something. Don't confuse goodness with greatness.