Prime for Prime, Who Wins @ 168, James Toney vs Joe Calzaghe?

Toney

 

Calzaghe UD.

I think Calzaghes style is all wrong for Toney.

 

Nah thats definitely somebody trolling under an alias

 

That is some strategy to have an alias that sounds like a bigger goofus than your original.
atsch

I guess they can't escape the imbecility and just have to go with it.

 

you mean he didn't duck ward?

but yeah, if the guy is serious he obviously doesn't know **** about boxing and we should welcome and educate a noob like him. WELCOME NOOB! watch some boxing BEFORE commenting, not the other way around

 

no, he didn't. not at all any time the fight was feasible. unless you have a source and then i'll look like a dick

 

Toney's the better boxer, but a little weight-drained @ 168

 

well this quote is stupid and i'll take care of that first:

ali beat foreman (beaten beats unbeaten)
schmeling beat louis (beaten beats unbeaten)
duran beat leonard (beaten beats unbeaten)

now, as I said he never challenged toney when it was feasible. toney as fighting at cruiser when calzaghe beat lacy. there was NO ****ING WAY he could lose the weight. if it's true, it was a pathetic idle challenge by calzaghe, to make himself look good, like he WANTED to fighted the best knowing it would never happen.

 

though anglo saxon, i get the feeling your yanking my dick on this one

 

haha, alright i gotcha. this is like the calzaghe is greatest of all times thread where people must have been taking a **** cause some of that stuff was ridiculous. it took a while but i have to believe that thread was bogus, much like your posts. you hooked me dude, well played.

 

well he sure did slap the **** out of RJJ and had his blood every where.

thats somthing you can't change no matter how many post you make hating on him :good

 

Log out. Cancel membership. Check into rehab to dry out.

 

I think I pick Joe Calzaghe to win this one. He was more consistent than James Toney. Toney was great but he had those fights where he looked lethargic, and with Calzaghe's workrate I could see Calzaghe out fighting James and winning a decision. I think what losses the fight for James is James himself. Skill for skill I think James wins this fight, but in the ring I see Calzaghe winning.

 

How do you know, you have been a member of this site for about 20 minutes?!

atsch I smell an alias with an axe to grind....

 

Heart says Toney, head says Calzaghe.

It's a damn shame that JT never got a crack at JC, Thimply, or Benn.