Prime for Prime, Who Wins @ 168, James Toney vs Joe Calzaghe?

Not the first one.

 

:deal

 

My boy Toney by decision.

 

it wasnt at 168

 

Yes, you would have to be a MORON to think that Joe Calzaghe is overrated and has a weak resume. Those sort of horrifically outlandish opinions can't be justified or explained, they are simply moronic.

Grow up you sour little vagina.

 

Dinamita he has a point, its weird how much you dislike Joe and **** all over his achievements. If you don't like the guy stop ****ing rambling on about it, everyone knows you dont and you think his career was gash. Get over it, please. Do you see me constantly digging at fighters i dont like? no, i keep it to myself like most other people on here.

 

calzaghe is toneys kryptonyte..too much workrate...calzaghe UD

 

calzaghe by a close UD, out works toney who stops mid fight to look for the house special

 

A fight similar to this is toney-jirov(great fight!) toney was able to break him down and counter punch him though jirov was winning round son workrate.....calzaghe is a much better version/fighter than jirov

 

"Lights Out"

 

Prime Calzaghe might KTFO Toney.

 

willie pep might KTFO Jake LaMotta but it ain't ****ing likely

 

Joe Calzaghe fans make me laugh.

 

Toney vs Calzaghe would have been a great fight, I would have loved to have seen that one. I think that Toney would have beatten him.

 

To be honest this is a tough call, I do remember Tony was getting beat in every aspect in boxing by Michel Nunn. Tony pulled lighting out of a bottle and KOed Nunn, but like Nunn Joe is a fast south paw. The question would be could he box Tony for 12 with out getting caught?