Both top form and fully motivated (Not the half assed Baer) Frazier is the more accomplished fighter, but I dont think he can take Max Baer at his best. I think Baer takes him out in a manner similar to Foreman, although not as dynamically.
I think Baer would nail Frazier with a big right hand and force a stoppage from behind. Frazier couldn't fight going backwards and Baer is just too vicious and powerful. Maybe Frazier could make Baer quit like Louis did with his body shots but a motivated Baer was an animal with a mammoth chin.
I think Baer would find it difficult to nail Frazier with his over hand right, but if he could ,Joe would go down,if he survives the early rocky moments, the balance of the fight would probably turn in his favour, but the Max of the Schmeling fight could stop him.
I think Frazier's bobbing and weaving would make Max miss badly, and then Joe would tear him up on the inside. Joe Frazier is simply far more talented than Max Baer.
Baer never reached his full potential. He clowned way too often and was sloppy. I think Joe would win but not easy.
On paper Baer should win, but it is easy to see him finding a way to lose. He didn’t always put away pressure fighters the way he should have.
Guys Baer is ridiculously over rated .. I don't see him lasting six rounds against Frazier .. he gets him way too often ...
The only punch Frazier was vulnerable to was the uppercut. I don't see how an overhand right plays to Baer's advantage in this instance. Frazier by tko.