Sort of irrelevant, but ortiz almost beat Maidana, but turned out to be the worst thing that happened to his career. Floyd had to sucker punch Ortiz to beat him. then Floyd smacked around his GF and went to jail. True story.
Hatton would have killed him to the body.hattons jaw was rock solid for 95% of his career,the floyd defeat ruined him along with bad living
Current Maidana? Toss up. He's much bigger and stronger than Hatton so he might be able to rough him up on the inside where Hatton likes to fight. Tough call.
Both have great puncher power. Maidana lasted 24 rounds with Mayweather. Hatton is the bigger body puncher, I believe. I can't really pick a clear winner but I have to go with Hatton on this.
I think at 147 it would have been a war that could have gone either way Would still favor Hatton at 147