Prime Louis Vs Prime Usky

I wouldn’t bet for or against either guy in this one. I would call it close to 50-50…if one of you guys has a time machine handy I would be glad to along for the ride and find out.

 

I don’t think you’re getting this.

 

By watching the available footage.

 

Do elaborate

 

Louis W KO 10

 

So you have seen Louis drop Cruiserweight sized men as if they have been shot and drop Joshua like behemoths like sacks of potatoes, and you claim that there are at least 10 Heavyweights that punch harder and that he is not such a hard puncher ? That's pretty ridiculous.

 

How do you know that you're a reliable judge of power on film?

 

Good points. There are certainly exceptions and a guy like James Toney is a great example. He looked like a fat slob as a heavyweight but was so relaxed and experienced in the ring he didn't burn up a lot of energy when he fought. Then again, Toney was a star high school football player in Michigan until he punched out (true story) Deon Sanders.

When it comes to endurance and conditioning, I would take boxers and MMA fighters over just about any other athlete.

 

I don't want to sound too harsh on the results of this project, but the methodology leaves a lot to desire. Without the actual tests, even so-called experts can be so wrong with their interpretations.

 

That's because you live in a bubble. There are a lot of better athletes in these aspects than boxers. I admit they probably would end up quite high in such multi-sport comparison for endurance, but definitely not the highest.

 

Explain how you can measure the power based on watching footage. That would be ground breaking for boxing community.

 

Basically this

unfortunately although louis is the greater fighter usyk is sort of a nightmare for him, especially if it was an older louis. A younger, more spry louis would give usyk more trouble than AJ though

I think Louis would beat the Usyk that fought AJ a couple days ago (assuming Louis is allowed to adjust to modern times with PEDs) but is 50/50 and might very well catch an L to a prime Usyk

 

Sure. That's always possible.

 

It's not exact science, just my observation and assessment.

 

But your observation has no possible methods to do it accurately. You act like your opinions are facts, but you have no arguments to back it up.