Fine, its like this... they pit 2 fighters who are much far or years away from them. Which is kinda illogical in some sense. There is no answer nor even how much arguement you cause there won't be a definite one. It's like having this Pokemon games(gawd I wish I never asked my younger brother what they were doing with this card, first of all I thought they were gambling at that young age... didn't knew it was that stupid Pokemon card)... Simple, you put fictional characters(like the prime for prime thing) and pit each other against them.
Nope YOU try again, get your facts straight. Ike fought Delahoya in 99 and fought Vargas in 2000, how the hell is that a 3 year layoff?:blood As for the Winky fight, Vargas hand was raised no matter how you look at it, therefore is a victory.
Of course we will NEVER truly know what woulda happened in fantasy H2H matchups, but I find it fun to debate them. I"M guessing you don't. To each his own.:good