Nunn was marhinally a btter fighter, Nunn was superbly talented, he faced and beat the better opposition and held a genuine title for the majority of his reign. Nunn would outbox Calzaghe to a narrow pnts decision, Calzaghe would only have been a contender in this era sitting below the likes of Nunn, Toney,Jones,Mcullam (all great fighters) He would be in the chasing pack Eubank, Watson Benn, Colling Reggie Johnson stable as very dangerous contender.
Calzaghe has a great statistical record for his P4P stautus, but his opposition lacks the quality of other P4P fighters.
Calzaghe is a real good fighter but no where near a s good as a lot of people seem to think. His record lacks true depth. In a few weeks before his time is done his true level will be exposed by a 43 B-Hop.