I would pick the Tyson that fought McBride to beat Joshua to be honest, definitely the Tyson that fought Danny Williams.
AJ is basically Frank Bruno with social media, and we saw what Tyson did to Bruno. Twice. Tyson would win by KO, maybe 3 or 4 rounds, even after his prime. At his peak, a round or two at most.
If you think AJ is remotely close to Bruno in anything outside of looks and both being powerful you really aren't seeing what skills fighters have nor the vast differences between fighters. Believe what your eyes are telling you, you'll continue to be confused
Lol! Why is this even a question? Only delusional Brit AJ fans are going to pick him. Tyson would massacre AJ. Tyson massacres every HW of the last 20 years.