Prime Vs. Prime Toney Vs. Calzaghe At 168 Or 175

I'd pick Toney by close UD. He won't knock Joe out.

 

tony by ud...hell no no way he tkos him but tony was a master at 168 and would win at 8 or 9 rounds

 

Toney by UD. I've noticed how many have said Joe's style is all wrong for Toney. But it usualy ends withthat sentence.

James Toney was an ACCURATE counterpuncher, who was also aggressive. Joe's not known for his defense, and being someone who throws so much, will leave him open to counters all day. And Toney's defense was too good anyway and his chin good enough to cover what gets through.


James Toney 9 rounds to 3.

 

James Toney was a serious bad ass, why even make threads like these man...for real lights out is the **** and nothing else matters. These threads are pointless because we already know James Toney is the biggest bad ass ever. Him and Mayorga should have a reality show together. (if only mayorga knew english..)

 

At 175 Joe wins. At 168 Toney wins. :!:

 

Toney is an overrated roid freak.

Calzaghe would take him by wide decision.

Toney is overrated because of his nationality, mouth and colour.

 

Toney beats him at both weights via UD

 

Calzaghe UD

His speed, footwork, in and out movement, akward-angle shots would be enough to beat Toney. Toney was succeptable to volume punchers with good movement.

 

Tony by KO!!!!!!

I think were all forgetting what he did before moving to heavyweight........

 

:yep

 

toney wins by easy ud or late ko

 

I was just kidding about the weights but seriously no way Toney wins 99 of 100. More like 51 out of 100. The only way Toney wins 99 of 100 is if he has the Tiberi judges backing him up everytime.

 

Calzaghe by close decision. In his prime i think he's too quick & could beat him from the outside.

 

Joe at 168.

I'll let you know about 175 after I've seen Joe fight at that weight.