Prime Whitaker v Prime Mayweather @ 135 & 147 who wins??

Can't we make this thread a sticky? Just so we don't have yet another PBF vs. Sweet Pea thread made the moment this one disappears.

 

i think pbf would keep the fight in the pocket, alot of the tricks sweet pea had i dont think would be all that effective against pbf.his best fights were to me against nelson, mc girt, mayweather.i think prime for prime mayweather jr is better then all of those guys and could really win ud over sweet pea.

im not sure what his game plan would be, but it would be what ever he needed to do to win.i like mayweather because how he can adjust when he needs to, same thing about sweet pea as well !!

 

whitaker takes it, he's just better.

 

Sorry my bad,I meant the other way around
Mayweather UD at 135
Whitaker UD at 147

 

Whitaker UD at both weights.

 

So you place Mayweather what number 1 or 2 H2H at 135?

 

Whitaker was at his very best at LW while Floyd was struggling with the likes of Castillo. I don't get either choice. Whitaker was just the better fighter, regardless of whether or not you're trying to be subjective.

 

Hard to say,maybe I'm a little Floyd hater so Mayweather goes in the back but I still see him winning at 135

 

Taht is my choice,I don't like Floyd or anything,actually I more or less hate him but I respect you'r choices and these are mine,wrong or right

 

Whitaker: UD. Same outcome for both weight classes. He's just better at most things.

Over 12 rounds, something like: 8-4.

 

They are 2 Grand Masters of the Pure Art. But I think Whitaker was Grander and Purer. Whitaker by SD at 135, Whitaker by UD at 147.

 

Agreed.