The OP said a prime version of Zab Judah not the recent one who lost to Amir Khan. TheZab Judah of the Kostya Tszyu fight would give Oscar a good fight but I think he would still lose but it wouldn't be as one sided as people are making it out to be.
That's true. I think the Judah of the Tszyu fight would be very competitive until around round two when Judah steps back and Oscar lands the first flush lefthook and makes him either Chicken dance or puts him to sleep.
Oscar puts him to sleep. That avatar is looking clean, IsaL. Repping Juan Manuel Marquez is never a bad thing; the guy is an Aztec Warrior.
They were not on two diffrent levels. And Oscars jab would get countered by Zab easily. You dont jab a southpaw. And especialy not one like Zab. But yeah Zab would lose but it would be competetive? 8-4 type decision. Zab would have his moments. But Oscar would eventualy walk him down. Oscar could get a late tko also. But he would get a Cotto pizza face in the process.
Zabs hand speed would make things interesting.... For about 3 rnds.... Oscar catches him with something big and stops him in 7