How in the hell is Hatton still on the list and Pavlik isn't on at all? Who does he need to beat in order be on the list? Cotto got on the list for beating..........Who? Mosley (not decisively) and Judah ( Was he on the list when they fought)?
the only only name on Pavliks ledger is Taylor. Miranda hasnt beaten anyone of merit, other then a sick Allen Green. I can see him at maybe 15 on the list, but he needs some good title defenses before he gets bumped up, but he'll probably get KOd before that.
I think that the win over Miranda and the wins over Taylor should give Pavlik a higher spot than hatton right now.
In my eyes its not unreasonable to think that Hatton is better than Pavlik, although I don't consider it so.
what about jmm!!!!!????? he got flawed 3 times by pac and won against an old and all be it retired mab but is ranked in the top 5 p4p!?? why!!???
I agree.. He had two decisive victories over two fighters that he was supposed to lose too! Hatton loss the fight he was supposed to lose! Cotto won one fight decisively against Zab (whatever) and had a questionable win over Mosley! I'm not saying that cotto should not be on the list. But, Hatton definitely shouldn't.. I'm using Cotto because I think Miranda is better opposition compared to Judah... And Taylor and Shane are similar as far as opposition level for their respective weight class..With taylor having the edge.
tottally agree pavlik has been facing the most dangerous figthers in his division onthe other hand i always desagree whit the ring magazine rankings
With Calzaghe at #3 and Hopkins at #7 do you think this upcoming fight can help Calzaghe's legacy if he wins? A lot of folks on here wont give props to Calzaghe is he beats an old hopkins. I certainly will be moving Hopkins if he can beat calzaghe.
Pavlik beat Taylor(16) twice who beat Popkins(#7) twice and drew with Winky(#9) and you put him at #20atsch