Quit with the Mayweather is P4P#1 BS

If he beat Froch, Groves, DeGale, or Dirrell in impressive fashion and showed he hadn't lost a step, he should be back in the mix the same as Floyd was beating a much smaller Marquez after his layoff in 2009. Ring put Floyd back at #2 for that.

As far as Rodriguez goes, he's probably no worse than Victor Ortiz, Guerrero, or Berto. He was ranked #8 or #10 or something at super middle when Ward fought him. Now he's ranked #13 (boxrec) at cruiserweight. It's also the impressive way that Ward handled his opponent that doesn't make the victory meaningless.

 

What a stupid thread

 

Lol

 

Some peeps tend to forget Mayweather lost his first fight to Castillo and almost lost to C level Maidana in there first fight and yall say he's p4p lol



Meanwhile sergey has fought and dominated Hopkins one of the best defensive fighters alive and B+ level Pascal in less than a year

 

p4P 1 don't have hard fights with Maidana fact

 

Wlad
Kovalev
Rigo
GGG

 

Hopkins moves from one corpse division to another bypassing all the hardest challengers. He hid from Jones, Toney, and Calzaghe at middleweight, then moved to light-heavyweight as soon as that division emptied out and super middle heated up. Father time finally caught up with that old man and he ran into a real opponent named Sergey Kovalev. The miracle is that he didn't break a hip running from Kovalev all night. Beating Hopkins fifteen years ago was an accomplishment. Now, it should just be a given.

 

Mayweather just completely shutout Canelo and Pac just very convincingly beat a p4p #3 in Bradley very recent. Again, either of those wins are much better than what Golovkin has ever done. In fact, Golovkin wont even go up 1 division to fight current p4p #3 Andre Ward, Pac just beat p4p #3 on his 10th weight division as World Champion.

 

Bernard is still very very good defensively even Kovalev said that and he don't strike me as a guy that lies

 

Khan top five? Khan belongs nowhere near any P4P list.

 

I'll give Mayweather credit for his win against Canelo. That was one of if not actually his best win ever. But maybe we were just overestimating Canelo. Or maybe Mayweather only really started showing his age against Maidana. I really can't see 2007 Mayweather having any difficulty against a fighter of Maidana's caliber.

Only a fool would place Bradley at #3. I have him in my top 20, but he doesn't belong in the top 10. He's good, not great, and he was better at 140. The only people who put him that high are the one's who don't watch his fights and see he was gifted a series of robberies by incompetent women judges.

 

It doesn't matter if his technique is perfect. He doesn't have the physical tools to execute anymore. That's why Chad Dawson made a meal out of him.

 

Klitschko fights a string of undefeated, top 3 rated fighters, such as olympic gold champ and wba champ Povetkin, undefeated highly rated Pulev, and now fighting undefeated top rated Jennings - DSG says "Klit hasn't fought anyone decent in a while"

 

Pascal is A level. Lets not hate on him just because he lost to Sergei