rank them by order.

here is mine :
p4p :
Rocky Marciano
Ezzard Charles
Jersey Joe Walcott
Joe Louis
Archie Moore


h2h :
Rocky Marciano
Joe Louis
Jersey Joe Walcott
Ezzard Charles
Archie Moore

 

P4P
Ezzard Charles
Archie Moore
Joe Louis
Rocky Marciano
Jersey Joe Walcott

H2H
Joe Louis
Rocky Marciano
Ezzard Charles
Jersey Joe Walcott
Archie Moore

 

good enough

 

why moore over marciano p4p ? don't you get he was actually bigger , and by this i mean not only having 1" of height and 8" of reach advantages , i also mean he was at least as massive. he had to spit the meat in order to make weight.
marciano never tried making 175 , had he try , it was easier for him than to moore.

why louis over marciano p4p ? that is an (even bigger) absurd.
why ? because he beat buddy baer , it counts somehow but this is not a talented fighter.

and h2h it is so clear marciano was the best simply because he

This content is protected

.

offensively bad lists.
i even did not mention other problems in them.

 

joseph fritzl is your dad that is the only way to explain the way your mind works:yep

 

exactly , only people who are the sons of their grandfather like yourself think that losing by stoppage is a superior achievement to winning by stoppage. :hi:

 

both my granfather's were dead years before i was born unlike yours fritzl jnr:hi:

 

Just a question frankenfrank, please answer. Why, when every single poster on this site despises you and takes absolutely nothing you've ever posted half-way seriously, do you continue to post and believe your opinions are of any merit whatsoever? You're the joke in every thread you post in. A world class troll though, I'll give you that.

 

my questions are only for the ones that want to read them.
no duty of visiting my threads.
put me on ignore.
some may not , let them see my questions.
still i learn interesting facts here from time to time but mostly facing the ridiculous mythical epic beliefs about the likes of louis and even an over rating of duran and hagler that were great fighters , but it does not mean they were untouchables or could not have been hurt , especially duran.

about the despise thing : i guess i don't care about what you mention.

 

You make a good point, Marciano and Moore were around the same size in the ring and Marciano won. Moore was possibly past prime but no one would pick him to beat Rocky in his prime

The general feeling around here is Marciano won because it was heavyweight and Moore was better at LHW. But imo Moore never beat anyone that great at LHW himself and would have had much the same problem against a 175lbs version of Marciano

Now when it comes to Charles/Louis they were way past it when they fought Marciano