Rank These Fighters By Their Accomplishments

Ezzard Charles
Carlos Ortiz
Carlos Monzon
Marvin Hagler
Tommy Hearns
Michael Spinks
Eder Jofre

Likely, based purely on resume/accomplishments. Spinks is a tough one to rank.

 

Mine - this is tight in some areas of the list though -
Charles
Monzon
Ortiz
Spinks
Hagler
Hearns
Jofre

I know i'll get detractors for the Spinks- Hagler situation, but i accept that could possibly wrong or right.

This is quite funny though, because Jofre may be top (Charles?) if it were strictly a p4p list

 

1. Ezzard Charles
2. Carlos Monzon
3. Carlos Ortiz
4. Marvin Hagler
5. Thomas Hearns
6. Michael Spinks
7. Eder Jofre

 

Charles seems to be undisputed king of this thread!!!

 

1) Ezzard Charles
2) Carlos Monzon
3) Carlos Ortiz

The top three are quite solid, then it becomes a more level playing field:

4) Michael Spinks
5) Marvin Hagler
6) Thomas Hearn's
7) Eder Jofre

 

As he should be:good

Nobody else on that list comes close to matching his resume, despite the fact that all of them are legendary fighters.

 

Ezzard Charles
Marvin Hagler (I had him edging Ray and beating Vito twice)
Carlos Ortiz
Tommy Hearns
Carlos Monzon
Michael Spinks
Eder Jofre

Hagler, Ortiz, Hearns, Monzon and Spinks are very hard to distinguish accomplishment-wise.

 

You're right , he is a lock for number 1 imo (as in everyone else's!) , and Jofre is the undisputed bottom place here it seems , that is right though. However , he was a great fighter , one of the best ever imo, the fact that he's bottom of this list is the main reason why many dont rate him as high as i do as a ATG - achievement. But he was said to be absolutely amazing in his prime, got beat twice by a very good fighter who seemed to be his bogeyman, and then comes back past his prime and at a higher weight and wins all his remaining fights at the top level - greta fighter imo

 

Hearns above Monzon? Interesting, he would be one of the fighters I'd rank highly based largely on head to head ability.