Rank these fighters only using a p4p criteria

I rate Mayweather as one of the top ten fighters of all time and Ray somewhere near that but I put Ray top because of his opposition and Floyd second.
Manny 3rd and last place to Roy.

 

My first thought is. Open to changing my mind though.

Mayweather Jr.
Roy Jones Jr.
SRL
Pac

 

https://www.boxingforum24.com/threa...-been-born-the-same-year-as-r-leonard.625406/

 

Why would you rate Roy above Ray?

 

^^^^^ same for me

 

I know right! I feel Ray would have done better vs Griffin than Roy did...or do you think I am being to simplistic or harsh?

 

I think Leonard's acheivements get a bit overstated. Jones had some very good wins like over Toney, had success up a lot of weights, and looked amazing. Don't get me wrong, I don't think there's much in it, but I gave the edge to Jones.

 

You think Toney in that bout was better than Hearns, Duran or Benitez?

 

1. Ray Leonard
He beat a top 3 lightweight, a top 3/5 Middleweight and a top 10 welterweight. And those 3 fighters are all in my top 50 pfp ever. He has a few other good wins like Benitez and Kalule.

2. Floyd Mayweather Jr
Good wins against two top 10 welterweights, (Pac and Del a Hoya) but not as impressive as Leonard vs Hagler. Great looking résumé and a defence Specialist

3. Manny Pacquiao
Only slightly behind Mayweather in résumé, 2 wins over a top 10 lightweight (Marquez) and obviously the only 8 weight champion.

4. Roy Jones Jr
Ahh... It's such a Shame I have to put Jones last because I think he's more skilled than the 3 above but his résumé isn't all too impressive. He has beat a top 10 welterweight (Tito), a top 15 middleweight (Hopkins) and obviously Toney and Ruiz

 

Inches and fractions
Centre line
Would have got hit more
Bigger biceps
Awful

 

Do fans agree
I read it on quora
Someone said in another thread

 

1. SRL
2. Roy Jones Jr.
3. Mayweather Jr.
4, Pac

 

This.

Though I'd flip a coin between Floyd and Pacman as both are super fighters (Floyd undefeated and more talented, Manny's resume and multi-division achievements). SRL's record speaks for itself but I doubt too many fighters have left watchers mouths agape as much as Jones at his peak did. You can quibble about his resume but no one I've seen was as dominant at world class level for such a long period. He basically made everyone he fought look stupid from 1989-2003.

 

1.SRL
2. Mayweather
3. Pac
4. Jones