Rank these recent fighters ATG status...

I can accept if you have pac top 20 but not top 10, he basically needs to beat mayweather 147,marquez 140,williams 160 and bute at 168 to get in the top 10 lists of most people, old dudes who fought 700 times have those position locked, difficult to get in.

 

This.

 

Manny Pacquiao... Top 20
Floyd Mayweather... Top 40
Roy Jones... Top 50
Lennox Lewis... Top 70
Bernard Hopkins... Top 60
Oscar de la Hoya... Top 60

 

I'd move most back.

 

Im actually on your side on this one, i think pac and jones are top 20 even 10-15. Mayweather is top 30,lennox lewis top 40, hopkins top 40,oscar top 60

 

Manny Pacman is one
Bernard Hopkins is 2
Oscar Delahoya 3
Lennox Lewis 4
Roy Jones 5
Floyd Mayweather 6

 

Wait he has to beat Bute at 168 to be top 10?

He's still ****ing human. Imagine if Ivan Calderon had moved up through the weight divisions, KOing Morales, Barrera, Cotto etc. and then being asked to win titles at middle and super-middle to be above Duran and SRL.

 

+20 all of them are fine for me.

 

according to some oldtimers he does, I say williams-floyd win puts him in the top 10

 

Manny Pacquiao... Top 30
Floyd Mayweather... Top 50
Roy Jones... Top 70
Lennox Lewis... Top 50
Bernard Hopkins... Top 60
Oscar de la Hoya... Top 100

 

mayweather deserves to be in top 40 imo

 

jones top 70 really?

 

Well, the top 30 is still inside the top 70, if that makes you feel any better. I happen to think Jones is over-rated. He was brilliant, but he's still over-rated. I'm not having that argument here, though; too many children of the 80s and 90s who think he's the second coming, just like Tyson .