Rank these ten fighters (1-10) as you believe them to fall all time.

1 Shane Mosley
2 Mike McCallum
3 James Toney
4 Ronald Wright
5 Felix Trinidad
6 Marco Barrera
7 Eric Morales
8 Juan Marquez
9 Ricardo Lopez
10 Joe Calzaghe

 

1. Mike McCallum
2. Marco Antonio Barrera
3. Erik Morales
4. Felix Trinidad
5. James Toney
6. Shane Mosley
7. Joe Calzaghe
8. Ricardo Lopez
9. Winky Wright
10. Juan Manuel Marquez

 

Tito over Shane??? Based on what:huh

 

People McCallum was great but greater than Morales and Lopez? I think not

 

Because he was a picture perfect undefeated champion who actually cleared out his division. Far greater than even the likes of Calzaghe

 

James Toney
Felix Trinidad
Marco Antonio Barrera
Ricardo Lopez
Shane Mosley
Eric Morales
Mike McCallum
Juan Manuel Marquez
Joe Calzaghe
Winky Wright

 

Well why would you put shane above tito? Explain please.

 

Good list...

I havent seen lots of McCallum or Lopez to be honest, a decent amount but not enough to judge vs the others who I have seen loads of.

I agree with Mosely moving up the ranks after that brilliant win, Id have him on the same level as Morales & Barrera also.

Ps. Always nice to see Morales get a good placing, I also think Morales is underrated - even tho he is appreciated for giving great fights, he is underrated for his overall skillset by too many fans.... he aint no Gatti.

:good

 

Based on that I am not drunk on his performance.

It wouldnt have even been a question till yesterday, and a win over Margo, however impressive, doesnt put him ahead of Tito on an All time list for me.

These lists are purely subjective, so if you disagree fine. I think its close, if that helps, and i can see the argument for having i the other way round. I dont think JonOli pulled those specific names out of thin air. It's those names for a reason, they are all pretty much interchangeable (with the odd exception)

The only one I really debated was putting Toney ahead of Shane. I could change my mind on that every 10 minutes.

 

Anyone who ranks Calzaghe above 8 needs their ass whipped. Period.

 

Or slapped

 

atsch

 

I have him 7th.

I gave him the nod over Lopez, both weak resumes, but Lopez didnt fight anyone of the caliber of Hop, let alone beat one. That shaded it for me. I'm happy with 7.

Post your lists.

 

He throws 100 atsch a round

 

looks good:good