Rank these ten fighters (1-10) as you believe them to fall all time.

Mcallum
Barrera
Toney
Morales
Calzaghe
Trinidad
Mosley
Lopez
Wright
Marquez

 

Difficult task. All of these guys are a very similar level of fighter, some of the great of their generation with most not quite on the all-time level. Roughly as follows:

1. McCallum
2. Lopez
3. Toney
4. Trinidad
5. Morales
6. Barrera
7. Mosley
8. JC
9. Winky
10. JMM

 

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

I would have him last. I think Winky and JMM have better resumes.

 

1. Trinidad - simpy the best WW in the last 15 years
2. McCallum - most avoided fighter of the late eighties. Awesome technique.
3. Morales - only fighter to beat a peak Pac. A beast at 122.
4. Toney - just on talent alone, though wasted..could have been a top 5 ATG
5. Lopez - less stellar resume but cleaned out Miniflys
6. Calzaghe - hated by Nardtards..but his achievements speak are envied.
7. Mosley - My fav fighter. Can only rate him after his next fight (some think it was a fluke)
8. Marquez - another solid and technically boxer-puncher
9. Barrera - His losses to Jones and the way he wanted to quit in Pac I lowers my opinion of him.
10. Wright - Great defense. But that's all.

 

Yeah, the long forgotten prehistoric era of the eighties is real "old school"

 

Gotta update this list now

1. Erik Morales
2. Marco Antonio Barrera
3. Mike McCallum
4. Ricardo Lopez (I am on the fence with Lopez, a brilliant fighter, been studying him a lot lately, can't make a fair assement on him but he was an undefeated champion with a long title run, but the resmue is not stellar)
5. Felix Trinidad
6. Shane Mosley
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. James Toney-Great at 160 and 168. Anything above that other than Jirov I am not impressed with too much other than chin.
9. Winky Wright
10. Joe Calzaghe

 

It annoys me when people overrate Lopez to ****. Most people never even saw the guy fight, they just wanna make out that they know more than everybody else.

The guy was a fine fighter but his resume is very thin.