Ranking the Heavweight 'nearly men'

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Longcount, Sep 21, 2010.


  1. Longcount

    Longcount boxing Full Member

    5,107
    3
    Nov 1, 2009
    What we have here is a collection of heavyweights who either unsuccessfully challenged for a major title (WBC/WBA/IBF) or campaigned at world level during the 80s, 90s and into the 00s (ignoring WBO, WBF, WBU belts).

    There are some worthy contenders here and some less legitimate ones to spice things up.

    But, how would you rank these guys (from 1 to 20) prime 4 prime ?

    • Henry Akinwande
    • Lionel Butler
    • Bert Cooper
    • Jesse Ferguson
    • Alex Garcia
    • Andrew Golota
    • Jorge Luis Gonzales
    • Michael Grant
    • Joe Hipp
    • Ike Ibeabuchi
    • Phil Jackson
    • Ray Mercer
    • Danell Nicholson
    • Brian Nielsen
    • Samson Po'uha
    • Razor Ruddock
    • Corrie Sanders (South African, not T-Rex)
    • Jimmy Thunder
    • David Tua
    • Jeremy Williams
     
  2. EverLast

    EverLast Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,175
    6
    Oct 20, 2009
    is he really a nearly man? i mean corrie sanders actually won the WBO heavyweight title by knocking the **** out of Wladmir Klitscko, who some demented ****ers on here refer to as one of the greatest :shock: of all time :patsch
     
  3. Longcount

    Longcount boxing Full Member

    5,107
    3
    Nov 1, 2009
    Well Mercer and Akinwande also held the WBO strap, but the level of competition for that organisation's belt wasn't that hot at the time.

    As I said in the opener, they only qualify for the list if they didn't hold the WBA/WBA/IBF belts. Briggs doesn't qualify because he was the lineal champion and because he has a wheezy chest.

    I am with you on the Sanders issue though - for some reason people feel the need to mythologise fighters like him, Ibeabuchi and Tua like the were the second coming. :lol:
     
  4. TerryESB

    TerryESB The Final Boss Full Member

    13,376
    434
    May 4, 2009
    The wacky Pole. He had way many chance to be Heavyweight champion more than anyone else of this list.
     
  5. kostya by ko

    kostya by ko Boxing Addict

    5,579
    4,372
    Feb 18, 2005
    Some interesting match-ups in that 20.

    Can I add David Haye in there?
     
  6. Zakman

    Zakman ESB's Chinchecker Full Member

    31,866
    3,117
    Apr 16, 2005
    Here's how I would rate them

    Mercer
    Ruddock
    Tua
    Sanders
    Golota
    Cooper
    Ibeabuchi
    Grant
    Thunder
    Hipp
    Akinwande
    Butler
    Ferguson
    Jackson
    Nicholson
    Gonzalez
    Williams
    Pouha
    Garcia
    Nielson
     
  7. exumspate

    exumspate Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,471
    207
    May 6, 2010
    1. Ike Ibeabuchi - The best of the bunch....
    2. Ray Mercer - started too late and forgot to train too often...
    3. David Tua - See Po'uha, add partying...
    4. Andrew Golota - Froze or came unglued on the biggest stages...
    5. Corrie Sanders - Confidence and training issues...
    6. Bert Cooper - 'Smokin Crack' had all the tools but....
    7. Samson Po'uha - Ate his way out of a championship
    8. Razor Ruddock - too limited and then got Tyson'd...
    9. Alex Garcia - His downfall baffles me...
    10. Henry Akinwande - lacked the power...
     
  8. Uconn1986

    Uconn1986 Member Full Member

    349
    11
    Sep 26, 2009
    1. Golota
    2. Ibeabuchi
    3. Mercer
    4. Tua
    5. Sanders
    6. Ruddock
    7. Akinwande

    If Golota was all there mentally, no doubt he would have been champ