Thoughts on my p4p list? Few notes before I show the list. - bud is #1 for me due to his unification efforts and dominance while doing so - nelo and ggg are tied - Thurman makes my 4 spot for gritty wins over porter and Garcia. 2 high quality championship fighters - Garcia gets my 5 spot for a super dominant over broner going up in weight - Lomo isn’t higher because he does have 1 loss and he hasn’t dominant anyone we didn’t expect him to. - Spence @ 7 for his gutsy win vs kell brook - badou jack is a sleeper pick. Wins vs bute, groves, cleverly are excellent championship caliber wins. He should have also been awarded the fight vs degale - charlos to me are the hottest up and coming fighters out so thy can be 9 and 10 Omissions: rigo needs more fights. He had the skill of top 3 p4p but needs more activity. Beating lomo could instantly boost him anywhere 1-3 Inoue needs more fights vs top tier talent before I can put him in the top 10 1. Bud 2. Nelo 2b. Ggg 4. Thurman 5. Garcia 6. Loma 7. Spence 8. Badou 9. Jermall 10. Jermell
Why do the big guys like light heavyweights, cruiserweight and heavyweights never get a look-in on any p4p lists?
Terrible honestly. Rungvisai not being top 10(probably should be top 5) is probably the biggest flaw but there are tons of bad choices.
I don't think the Charlo bros should be on the list. I'd have GGG and Terry in the #1 a/b position. Loma at 3 Nelo 4, Garcia 5, Thurman 6, Rig 7, Spence 8, Inoue 9, Kovalev 10
Honestly, that's a terrible list. Rate it? Like 2 or 3 out of 10. If we're grading it deserves an F. Just the arrangement is deranged. Putting Canelo and GGG together and Thurman above Lomachenko? Then including Jack and the Charlo twins at the bottom instead of Usyk, Kovalev, Lara, Rigondeaux, Inoue, or Estrada? What the hell are you thinking?
Good to know guys like uysk, inoue, rigo, And Estrada are getting rated for what we think they would do to people. Whether or not they are actually fighting anyone. While guys like Keith Thurman and the charlo brothers are actually kicking relevant fighters asses and people want to exclude them from the list. Makes sense
Who are the top competition the Charlos are beating again? I'll need reminding as I must of missed it.
One of the very worst P4P lists in the history of the internet. Log off, and go sit in a dark corner and think about what you did.
Inoue has a strong resume already and a world champion. He’s dominated every fight and his depth as a fighter in terms of skills are p4p worthy. Actually, compared to the Charlo bros resumes there’s not much that separates Inoue from them. Aside they’ve been done fighting longer and had more fights. The quality of opposition is fairly equal. Rig has already proven he can beat p4p opposition so I’m unsure why you would even attempt to make that argument that he shouldn’t be mentioned on the p4p rankings? He beat Nonito easily who was on the p4p list
He beat donaire like 4 years ago. Might as well have Miguel cotto and Sergio Martinez on the list for what they were doing 4 years ago also. Inoue we need to see more before crowning him. HBO has been trying hard to get these little guys in the p4p list since Floyd retired and chocolatito get knocked off. Let’s see inoue a little more before we crown him.