Rate my p4p list...

1. Agree with, could probably argue others. But that is respectable
2. Should be GGG. Clearly beat Nelo.
4. Thurman isn't nearly that good, should probably be below Loma and Mikey Garcia
5.See above
6.See above
7.Decent placement, I still think Brook was more skilled, but spence is probably more skilled than anyone else in the division
8.Badou, he probably is worth mentioning but you could put someone else here and bump him down a few
9.Jermall is a decent pick but as a middleweight I'm not sure how he will do
10.Jermell hasn't done as much as jermall.

Right now boxing is in a weird place. I'd also say that Sergey Kovalev still shouldn't be written off. He is actually much better than GGG IMO (or at least was, not sure if he will have the same desire after being ripped off like that 2x and being a victim of boxing corruption). Sergey would be on top of the world if the judges had gotten the first fight correct. Depending on how he looks in his next fight you might need to consider moving him in.

 

****.

 

It's pretty poor, honestly having the Charlo's in the top 10 P4P list is putrid.

 

Bad list man.. Horrible to be honest... Just syin.. Take a good look at it

 

Loma isn't high for not dominating someone he wasn't expected to...must not have been around here for the Walters fight. And yet Garcia is at 5 for dominating Broner!?

Charlos are 9 and 10 for being hottest up and coming but yet in another post you said Inoue, Rigo, Usyk etc shouldn't be rated because of what we *think* they do to people!? Man honestly it is so inconsistent

 

True. I actually agree with you on Rig. I forgot just how inactive he’s been and he hasn’t looked great either. Inoue has been active and dominant against good opposition. So have the Charlo bros but they’ve been in the pro longer to accomplish what Inoue has accomplished in a fraction of the time

 

Honestly this list is terrible. I'm not being bias as
I'm fans of most of the people on the list, the fact that you don't
even have Rigo on the list is insane. It's crazy and it's hard to
take the list seriously after that first point.

Bud and Loma I'm fine with but then you have Badou Jack on the list who's biggest win is a draw
and he was knocked goofy by a journeyman only 3 years ago(and he never even avenged it). Golovkin
again, no issue, Spence and Thurman (probably my favorite active fighter) I have no problem with being
on the list, but objectively they'd be 9-10. Canelo I question why he's even on the list
as he arguably has losses against the 4 best fighters he's fought (Trout, Lara, Floyd, Golovkin).
Garcia I'm fine with, the Charlos (again I'm a fan), have both shown glimpses but don't
deserve a spot yet (especially over Rigo, Inoue, Kovalev and a few others.

 

1 GGG
2 Loma
3 Bud
4 Kov
5 Canelo
6 Wangek
7 Rigo
8 Thurman
9 Usky
10 Inoue

 

I don't understand why so many are butthurt it's just the guy's opinion.

 

He asked people to rate his list, that's why!

 

I hate this list, mods ban the OP and delete this thread.

 

Who have the Charlos beaten?

 

The are always simple minded folks in every area but much of the p4p rankings reflect the perception of the masses, not just due to the influence of the sports writers. Much of the time the sports writers are influenced by the public.

To be fair to Inoue....he’s in a weight class that doesn’t garner much attention from the Boxing world. In order to get attention in the lower weight classes you have to be something truly special which Inoue seems to be. It doesn’t mean the talent or depth of the division is weak, just under appreciated. I don’t believe his status as a p4p fighter has anything to do with credit for fights that have yet to happen, rather than his body of work in such a short period of time with a very impressive launch as a pro. He has faced very stiff competition as a green blue chip prospect creating a trajectory that rivals Loma.

Kovalev drops spots on the p4p rankings due to his losses to Ward....albeit controversially in both fights. Had he lost convincingly he most likely wouldn’t even be on the list. The Charlo bros are well on their way to breaking into the rankings but they haven’t done enough. Jamal probably is closer with a slightly better resume although Jermell has been more active. They’ve both been pretty dominant against Good opposition but haven’t beaten any great fighters. People who have them in the p4p rankings seem to be looking to give them credit for fights that haven’t happened yet.