Rate my post 1990 list

atsch You rate strictly on resume yet have Chavez as number 1? :rofl

Sorry, but that's an awful list. 3/10

 

Rate your list? Dog ****.

 

:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl

 

1/10

 

.5/10....sowwey:good

 

I was being generous

 

ellerbe knocks 9 marks off for not including Broner.

 

This is my alternative to it based on resume rather than perceived talent with p4p factor considered:




1. Mosley
2. Danny Garcia
3. Pacquiao
4. Marquez
5. Byrd
6. Froch
7. Bradley
8. GGG
9. Kovalev
10. Provodnikov


11. Toney
12. Reggie Johnson
13. Glen Johnson
14. Brewster
15. Mauricio Herera
16. Whitaker
17. Afolabi
18. Lebedev
19. Cunningham
20. Tarver


21. Vince Phillips
22. JCC
23. Frankie Randall
24. DLH





How come Garcia over Pacquiao ?
1. Getting KOd is a part of resume
2. Stopping drained Cotto and drained and past prime DLH does not count as much as most count these.
3. Morales was drained in his 2nd and more so in his 3rd fights vs Pacquiao.
4. Marquez is in fact 5 years older than Pacquiao and probably still has a back injury (which delayed his pro debut) and he still KOd him. But did he, or did he not step on Pacquiao's foot while doing so or at least in his 1st KD of him?

 

1. Toney
2. Calzaghe
3. Mayweather Jr
4. Jones Jr
5. Whitaker
6. Pacquaio
7. Morales
8. Barrera
9. Hamed
10. Eubank/Lennox/Oscar/Hopkins

Chavez was at his best in the 80s, likewise Nunn and Meldrick Taylor.