Rate these fighters' historical significance: ATG, HOF, borderline HOF, not deserving HOF

None of those are ATG.. The best of all of those to me is Roman Gonzales.Cotto and Donaire, Michalchevski at HOF.. Martinez and Hatton, Vargas, Margarito, Castillo, Bradley, Michalhevski borderline Hall of fame Judah, Garcia, Kovalev,Tarver, Pavlik all come up short.. Borderline HOF maybe, but I don't think they should get in so I put them at the bottom. If you want a list?
Gonzales,
Cotto,
Donaire,
Michalchavski,
Martinez,
Bradley,
Nietes,
Margarito,
Hatton,
Vargas,
Kovalev,
Tarver,
Garcia,
Judah,
Pavlik I look at the big wins. Pavlik at the end? Lost to an old Hopkins. If he were at the top he should have had enough to beat Hopkins. Kovalev did. Although there is Tarver, who lost to Hopkins but had three fights with Jones. Judah? Entertaining.. but inconsistent. Danny Garcia. Does ok in a weak era. Like I said none of these guys are ATG, although I think the list was put there because these guys are sort of questioned as where they rank.

 

Sergio Martinez: Border HOF kind of a late bloomer decent title run at 160
Miguel Cotto: HOF though I take off some points for vacant titles and injury wins
Antonio Margarito: While I think he legitimately beat Cotto I'm not sure he is HOF material.
Nonito Donaire: HOF for sure, low weights are not my area of expertise might be borderline ATG for the sub 126
Donnie Nietes: Not enough information
Roman Gonzalez: HOF
Zab Judah: Not sure if he is HOF he was undisputed at 147 and held titles at 140 its close. Was a little too inconsistent
Jose Luis Castillo: Fought Floyd on even footing, and beat Johnston and Diaz but got controversial wins vs Casamayor and Ngougo. I'd say border

Danny Garcia: I like Garcia but he has some controversial wins and it seems he will take 1 quality guy then fight someone completely below his depth. While he was a legitimate and unified 140lb champion he came up short in his biggest fights vs Thurman a clear loss and Porter in a close one. I would say border line

Sergey Kovalev: funny case going into the Ward fight I would say on pace to be HOF then he got stopped by Ward and Alvarez and Canelo and was on the verge vs Yarde. I think I'm letting present state get too much in my judgement

Fernando Vargas: I dont know, his biggest wins were close and his losses were devastating. I dont know if he had enough fights or that one big win to push him into the hall

Antonio Tarver: HOF worthy though he did mail it in vs Hopkins and Dawson
Kelly Pavlik: Was a big fan but I feel like his time at the top was too short. His best wins Taylor and Miranda were awesome at the time but I'm not sure they have aged the best. I wouldnt argue anyone who would put him in but if I had a vote I'd say no

Ricky Hatton: Big fan of Hatton not sure he has the resume for the HOF.
Timothy Bradley: HOF
Dariusz Michalchevski: HOF

No definite ATG fighters and a bunch of possible HOF guys that could be argued either way. Only a few there that I would say definitely HOF material

 

Sergio Martinez - HOF
Miguel Cotto - HOF
Antonio Margarito -not HOF
Nonito Donaire - HOF
Donnie Nietes - borderline HOF
Roman Gonzalez - ATG
Zab Judah - Not HOF
Jose Luis Castillo -borderline HOF
Danny Garcia - Not HOF
Sergey Kovalev - Not HOF
Fernando Vargas - Not HOF
Antonio Tarver- Not HOF
Kelly Pavlik - Not HOF
Ricky Hatton - Not HOF
Timothy Bradley - Not HOF
Dariusz Michalchevski - HOF

 

The following list:

Sergio Martinez HOF
Miguel Cotto borderline HOF
Antonio Margarito not deserving HOF
Nonito Donaire ATG
Donnie Nietes borderline HOF
Roman Gonzalez ATG
Zab Judah not deserving HOF
Jose Luis Castillo HOF
Danny Garcia not deserving HOF
Sergey Kovalev HOF
Fernando Vargas not deserving HOF
Antonio Tarver borderline HOF
Kelly Pavlik not deserving HOF
Ricky Hatton not deserving HOF
Timothy Bradley borderline HOF
Dariusz Michalchevski not deserving HOF

 

Personally, I think there's too many in the hall of fame. The Canastota hall of fame, there's too many there that shouldn't be in a legit hall of fame. So I am imagining a glorious fictitious HOF, where only the best of the best get in but due to politics a couple might sneak through the cracks...lol!
Anyway if that list, they only fighters I would include would be : Cotto, Donaire, Gonzalez and Michalchevski.

 

Zab and Hatton above Castillo?

 

Miguel Cotto-HOF
Nonito Donaire-HOF
Donnie Nietes- didn't see much of him
Roman Gonzalez-ATG
Antonio Tarver-Border HOF
Ricky Hatton-Border HOF
Timothy Bradley-HOF
Dariusz Michalchevski- Border HOF