***Rate these fighters***

I'll make Ray Robinson A++, because he is a class above IMO.

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A
Manny Pacquiao - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A+
Zab Judah - B+
Kelly Pavlik - B+
Cristian Mijares - [Haven't seen enough]
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Joe Calzaghe - A+
Juan Diaz - A (maybe B+?)
Ricky Hatton - A
Joan Guzman - B+
Wladimir Klitschko - A
Paul Williams - B
Edwin Valero - B (at this stage)

[/quote]

I dunno, something like that.

EDIT: I'll make Cotto an A.

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A
Manny Pacquiao -A
Bernard Hopkins -A
Zab Judah -B
Kelly Pavlik -B+
Cristian Mijares -B+
Juan Manuel Marquez -A
Joe Calzaghe -A
Juan Diaz -B
Ricky Hatton -B+
Joan Guzman -B+
Wladimir Klitschko -A
Paul Williams -B+
Edwin Valero -B

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A
Manny Pacquiao - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A+
Zab Judah -B+
Kelly Pavlik - A-
Cristian Mijares - A-
Juan Manuel Marquez - A+
Joe Calzaghe -A+
Juan Diaz -A
Ricky Hatton - A
Joan Guzman - B+
Wladimir Klitschko - A
Paul Williams - B+
Edwin Valero - B

 

Bigreg you forgot two pluses on BHop

 

B-Hop is damn near 43, it's truly amazing that he's still an A level fighter. A prime Hopkins was an A++ fighter. In his mid 30's he was an A+ fighter. Now, he's an A fighter.

 

there ya go:good

 

Never seen Ray Robinson

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A
Manny Pacquiao - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A (A+ in his prime, though he looked damn good against Tarver)
Zab Judah - B
Kelly Pavlik - B+
Cristian Mijares - never seen him fight
Juan Manuel Marquez - A-
Joe Calzaghe - A+
Juan Diaz - B+ (Maybe A-, only saw the Freitas fight)
Ricky Hatton - A
Joan Guzman - B+
Wladimir Klitschko - A-
Paul Williams - B+
Edwin Valero - B-

more

Shane Mosley - A-
Margarito - B+
ODLH - B-
Joachim Alcine - B-
Lucian Bute - B+
Mikkel Kessler - A

Add more and I'll rate em

Nonito Donaire - A-
Vernon Forrest - B-
Antonio Tarver - C

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A- (Need to see him some more to see if he can rise above this.)
Manny Pacquiao - A-
Bernard Hopkins - A+ (In his prime, one of the greatest ever.)
Zab Judah - B
Kelly Pavlik - A-
Cristian Mijares - A-
Juan Manuel Marquez - B+
Joe Calzaghe - A+
Juan Diaz - A-
Ricky Hatton - A+
Joan Guzman - A-
Wladimir Klitschko - A
Paul Williams - B+
Edwin Valero - B

 

NH

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A
Manny Pacquiao - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A
Zab Judah - B+
Kelly Pavlik - A
Cristian Mijares - A+
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Joe Calzaghe - A
Juan Diaz - A
Ricky Hatton - A+
Joan Guzman - B
Wladimir Klitschko - A
Paul Williams - A
Edwin Valero - A

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. -A+
Miguel Cotto -A-
Manny Pacquiao -A+
Bernard Hopkins -A-
Zab Judah -B+
Kelly Pavlik -A
Cristian Mijares -A
Juan Manuel Marquez -A+
Joe Calzaghe -B
Juan Diaz -A
Ricky Hatton -A-
Joan Guzman -A
Wladimir Klitschko -?
Paul Williams -A
Edwin Valero -B-

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A
Miguel Cotto - A-
Manny Pacquiao - A-
Bernard Hopkins - B
Zab Judah - C
Kelly Pavlik -B
Cristian Mijares - A (not up to speed enough with him)
Juan Manuel Marquez - B+
Joe Calzaghe - Supernatural
Juan Diaz - B+
Ricky Hatton - B
Joan Guzman - A
Wladimir Klitschko - B+
Paul Williams - A

 

JMM is defo in the same class as Hatton, Klit, Pavlik