***Rate these fighters***

bump

 

Pavlik the same level as Hopkins?? Facts and history show that to be false.....

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A+
Miguel Cotto - A-
Manny Pacquiao - A
Bernard Hopkins - A+
Zab Judah - C+ (HAS SERIOUSE ISSUES MENTALY)
Kelly Pavlik - A-
Cristian Mijares - A-
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Joe Calzaghe - A+
Juan Diaz - A-
Ricky Hatton - A-
Joan Guzman - A-
Wladimir Klitschko - A
Paul Williams - B+
Edwin Valero - C+

 

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - A
Miguel Cotto - B-
Manny Pacquiao - A
Bernard Hopkins - A
Zab Judah - C
Kelly Pavlik - B-
Cristian Mijares - B+
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Joe Calzaghe - A
Juan Diaz - B+
Ricky Hatton - B+
Joan Guzman - A-
Wladimir Klitschko - B-
Paul Williams - A-
Edwin Valero C

 

If SRR is an A+ then this is how i see it this list however has some fighters im not so sure about.

Floyd Mayweather Jr. - I would say A- B+ he has the skills and everything but his resume is very lacking and if he stays retired then the highest i can give him is a B+.
Miguel Cotto - A-. He is still young but looks very promising. He definately has the drive to become a full A. However if his career goes downhill he drops to B.
Manny Pacquiao - B+. He is very overhyped because of his last 2 wins. However if he were to go back to face the greats of his weight classes he would put up a very good fight yet i believe he would get beat most of the time by prime ATG.
Bernard Hopkins - very solid A. Very close to an A+. This guy to me is the greatest fighter of my generation. He is so damn smart.
Zab Judah - C+ B-. I dont see the big deal about him. He is a great journeyman but nothing more.
Kelly Pavlik - Hmm well although people used to talk about him as an A fighter i always saw him as a B fighter. His weight class is very lacking and i believe the only other good MW right now would beat him badly. A solid B is what i give him.
Cristian Mijares - Very confusing with this guy. He is from my hometown and he looks to have all the skills but his most recent fight confused the hell out of me. I would have said A- but now as it stands B maybe B+
Juan Manuel Marquez - A- right now. Has tremendous skills and would be hell and i beliebve beat alot of the former featherweight greats. His resume is not so strong but a few more top wins and he gets an A.
Joe Calzaghe - I dont get why people hate on him. Maybe its because he is foreign and cocky but this guy has alot of skill and beat Hopkins very convincingly. I have never seen anybody beat Hops like that. I give him an A.
Juan Diaz - too early yet but his loss to Campbell puts him at a B maybe B+
Ricky Hatton - Always thought this guy was overrated. I would say B or B+
Joan Guzman -Who knows? never liked him. I think he is too lazy to become great. B- or C+
Wladimir Klitschko - Great boxer. Also very hated for some reason. Probably his safety first style. PBF is the same though and he gets called a defensive master... I would say A-.
Paul Williams - Hasnt fought at the elite level enough. I think his size advantage is very misguiding on his real talent. I think a good boxer can make him look foolish. B.
Edwin Valero - What the hell?? Hmmm C maybe C-.

 

Floyd- A+
Cotto- B+
Pac- A
Hopkins- A+
Judah- B+
Pavlik- B
Mijarez- B+
Marquez- A+
Calzaghe- A
Juan Diaz- B+
Hatton- B-
Guzman- A-
Klit-B+
Williams- B+
Valero- B+

 

I agree. B-HOP still A caliber fighter!