Rate these great Bantamweights in order

Joltin' Jeff
Rose
Canizales
Harrera
Castilio
Martinez

 

No problem , so Harada beat Famechon in Australia but was KOd by Famechon in Japan

Just like he was KOd by Medel in Japan only 2 outpoint him , deservedly or probably not in Japan .

And 2 decisions , at least 1 of which a wrong decision , according 2 what i read , over a 7 years older and drained @ d weight himself Jofre 2 out of 2 in Japan .

This is d substance which gr8ness is made from :yep .

Still , i repeat , better than Lionel Rose , Orlando Canizales and Ricardo Lopez .

 

Boxrec rating system is a joke!

ESB did a Bantam consensus and the results for these 6 were:

11 Orlando
12 Rose
13 Harrera
T 15 Castilio
T 15 Chandler
19 Martinez

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=205064&page=5

 

ESB r8ing system is a worse joke !!
try checking its consensus top 2 @ HW 4 example .

4cing me 2 post n all time top 10 @ 118 based mainly on boxrecing which 4 me proved 2b a powerful tool only solidified by watching fights much more often than not , i'll do it now 4u :
1. Eder Jofre
2. Jorge Lujan
3. Raul Perez
4. Miguel Lora
5. Chucho Castillo
6. Rafael Herera
7. Ruben Olivares
8. Wayne McCullough
9. Khaokor Galaxy
10. Sung-Kil Moon


I considered Pete Sandstol , Sixto Escobar , Joe Lynch , Joe Burman but who knows about them ? janitor ? if u know what i mean .

so i went 4 only modern , and since it is always a surprisingly weak division compared 2 others in modern times i had 2 settle 4d Castillo , Herera , Olivares at least 4d time being ..

i really get tempted 2 put Donaire despite his poor resume @ d weight due 2 Darchiniyan and his 112 can b regarded as n "old time" 118 , quite d same with Darchiniyan and some 115 lbers .

Gaby Canizales might make it some day and is a definite top 20 .
have 2 eat

 

Canizales
Chandler
Rose
Herrera
Castillo
Martinez
Having said that I've always liked Herrera.

 

You should know better than to feed pirahnas.

 

Herrera was just brilliant in March of '72 in completely dominating, bloodying and dismantling Olivares for the full count...and this was near peak Olivares.

 

Jeff Chandler
Orlando Canizales
Rafael Herrera
Lionel Rose
Rodolfo Martinez
Chucho Castillo

 

IBRO has only 2 of this group mentioned at all that seems a little wrong to me...

1.Eder Jofre
2.Panama Al Brown
3.Ruben Olivares
4.Pete Herman
5.Manuel Ortiz
6.Carlos Zarate
7.George Dixon
8.Terry McGovern
9.Kid Williams
10.Fighting Harada
11.Joe Lynch
12.Johnny Coulon
13.Jeff Chandler
14.Bud Taylor
15.Sixto Escobar
16.Jimmy Barry
17.Frankie Burns
18.Memphis Pal Moore
19.Jose Becerra
20.Lupe Pintor
Just missing the cut: Pete Sanstol, Khaosai Galaxy, Charlie Phil *********, Jimmy Carruthers, Harry Jeffra, Jeff Fenech, Owen Moran, Lou Salica, Raul Raton Macias, Alfonso Zamora, Bushy Graham, Alphonse Halimi, Orlando Canizales and Abe Goldstein.

And I did my list before I even thought to look at this....

 

1. Your wife
2. Your Daughter
3. Your gay son
4. Your Mother
5. And your sister