Ray Leonard beat Marvin Hagler (W12) in April of 1987 for the Lineal MW World Title... and the WBC belt. In November of 1988 Leonard beat Donny LaLonde for the WBC SMW and LHW World titles. In July of 1988 Michael Nunn beat Frank Tate for the IBF MW world title. By the end of 1988 Nunn had wins over Tate and Juan Roldan KO8. Tate was a decent fighter and would go on to lose twice to Virgil Hill. Roldan was washed up, it was his last pro fight... Hearns stopped him in 4 rounds 1 year prior. In 1989 he beat Sumbu Kalambay KO1 and Iran Barkley WMD12. Don't be fooled by the KO over Kalambay, Nunn was not a big puncher... still don't know if Nunn could have outboxed Kalambay. Barkley gave him a lot of trouble, one judge had it even. In 1990 he beat Marlon Starling WMD12 and Donald Curry KO10. Both of these guys were washed up. Starling was a WW and still gave him hell, 1 judge had it even... Starling's only fight above WW. Curry was stopped in 8 rounds by Terry Norris in his next fight. In 1991 he lost to James Toney LKOby11. Yeah, he boxed well thru most of the first 10 rounds but he got caught. Toney really wasn't a big puncher.
I'll take Leonard by decision. Don't be fooled by the KO over Kalambay. It's a good win but had they fought 100 more times... it probably would have gone the distance every time. Somewhat of a fluke to be honest... plus, Kalambay's chin wasn't the best even though he was only down a few times. He was down in the 1st round 2 more times after his fight with Nunn (he came back to win both fights). Nunn barely beat Barkley and Starling... who else did he beat in those days?
I know that Leonard was already slightly past his prime in the summer and fall of 1988 when Nunn beat the unbeaten Frank Tate for the IBF Middleweight title and then two fights later added the Linear/Ring Magazine title with his 89-seconds knockout over Sumbu Kalambay, but if Ray fought Nunn at that particular time when he still had his momentum from the Marvin Hagler fight underneath him and approached the fight with the young undefeated Nunn the same way he approached the Hagler fight or his third fight with Duran, with the same zest and passion that he fought those two with, the juices flowing and all, I honestly feel he might've scored a dramatic come behind knockout against the undefeated but still raw Nunn, who only had his impressive win over Tate to back him. True Leonard would've had to endure Nunn's height advantage, which mind you was just a few inches shorter than Hearns, and reach advantage which also was a few shorter than Hearns as well as Nunn's southpaw style. But even past his prime it all depends on how Ray approaches a fight against a guy who didn't have any major mainstream appeal beyond the average/hardcore fight fan. This is definitely one for the video game if they could ever find a way to include all boxers on the video games but the fact that Nunn didn't have enough appeal, although he was good and talented while he was around, was the major reason why Ray didn't fight him even though Nunn rightfully was viewed as a threat. It's funny how Nunn didn't appeal to the mainstream masses but the guy that eventually scored a major dramatic/upset come from behind knockout over him, the undefeated James Toney by 11th round K.O., would go on to be a major player in the sport for years to come following that 1991 knockout over Nunn and I honestly believe Ray at his best even past his prime would've registered a dramatic finish as simular to that one, by a late come from behind knockout over a young, talented but still raw Nunn.
Yeah, he almost let the Barkley fight get away from him even though he seemed to have an extra gear. Think I had that one a draw on last scoring.
I didn't think there was any doubt on who won the fight I thought it was a pretty clear win for Nunn. As for the thread Nunn by clear decision if its a fair decision but the judges might go with Leonard based on his popularity if the fight is competitive.
Yeah, always a risk with judges if a superstar like Leonard is competitive with you. Hearns certainly found that out, but was never bitter about it, to his credit. Duran actually had one of the judges giving it to him against Benitez from memory and he was ahead against Hagler while the fight still was competitive.
SRL was slightly past his peak at that point while Nunn was just reaching his, not to mention that Nunn just has a lot going into his favor over the smaller man. Taller, longer reach, slippery, just as quick, and a tricky southpaw style that's a nightmarish combination for SRL to overcome.