Brewster's win column is better, but he also lost to Shufford, Liakovich and Ettiene (injured?) and went life and death with Meehan. I give the edge to Ruddock.
Brewster eats a lot of powerful shots, but eventually knocks Ruddock out within 9 in a very bloody battle. Brewster's endurance is the deciding factor but anything could happen since neither guy was great on defense and both his very hard. Might see a few trades too since both guys favor their left.
I wish I knew. This is one of those fights that could go either way. One thing is for sure. It would be an exciting brawl
Brewster is more durable and mentally tough to a fault, he walks through severe punishment and stops Ruddock in the late rounds. Then likely is ruined and never wins a meaningful match again.
Ruddock is more impressive on offence but Brewster is as tough as a tank. This is a close match; I might go with Brewster because he could bang in addition to being tough.