I agree that Clottey should've got the W. Although I only bothered to read the last paragraph on your post to get to the point sorry. I think he did more damage and I'm surprised that so many had Cotto winning.
Clottey failed to get the last few rounds, had 114-113 Cotto. I predicted a split decision win for Cotto, so it went as planned I thought Clottey had a better chance to actually win at the end there but he let it slip away. I hope Clottey doesnt subscribe to the Louie Collazo school of ****ing it up.